Page 4 of 42

Pet Food Reviews (Page 4)

Category: Pet Food
Reset Filters
Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Grain-Free Chicken, Turkey & Beef Variety Pack Wet Cat Food, 3-oz can, case of 24
Pet Food

Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Grain-Free Chicken, Turkey & Beef Variety Pack Wet Cat Food, 3-oz can, case of 24

9.1

Cats love the variety and flavors, great for picky eaters

Pros
  • Variety of Flavors
  • Health Benefits
Cons
  • Packaging Issues
  • Texture Preference
Popular Choice
Full Review →
Purina Pro Plan Vital Systems Chicken Entrée 4-in-1 Muscles, Brain, Immune & Bone Wet Kitten Food, 3-oz can, case of 24
Pet Food

Purina Pro Plan Vital Systems Chicken Entrée 4-in-1 Muscles, Brain, Immune & Bone Wet Kitten Food, 3-oz can, case of 24

9.4

Highly recommended for picky eaters and pets with specific dietary needs.

Pros
  • Moist Texture
  • High acceptability
Cons
  • Chemical Smell
Best Overall
Full Review →
Purina Pro Plan Vital Systems Chicken, Turkey & Salmon Entrée Variety Pack 4-in-1 Immune, Digestive, Kidney & Brain Wet Cat Food, 3-oz can, case of 24
Pet Food

Purina Pro Plan Vital Systems Chicken, Turkey & Salmon Entrée Variety Pack 4-in-1 Immune, Digestive, Kidney & Brain Wet Cat Food, 3-oz can, case of 24

8.1

Cats love the variety and taste, with great nutritional value.

Pros
  • Taste
  • Nutritional Quality
Cons
  • Price
  • Picky Eaters
Top Value
Full Review →
Purina Pro Plan Vital Systems Chicken & Salmon Entrée Variety Pack 4-in-1 Muscles, Brain, Immune & Bone Wet Kitten Food, 3-oz can, case of 24
Pet Food

Purina Pro Plan Vital Systems Chicken & Salmon Entrée Variety Pack 4-in-1 Muscles, Brain, Immune & Bone Wet Kitten Food, 3-oz can, case of 24

9.0

Highly recommended by vets and pet owners for kittens.

Pros
  • Taste Love
  • Vet Highly Recommended
Cons
  • Stomach Issues
  • Packaging Issues
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Pinkie Mice Frozen Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Pinkie Mice Frozen Reptile Food

7.2

Affordable and consistent quality, but size issues reported.

Pros
  • Affordable Pricing
  • Consistent Size
Cons
  • Size Issues
  • Quality Inconsistencies
Bargain Pick for the best price without major drawbacks
Full Review →
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Medium Mice Frozen Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Medium Mice Frozen Reptile Food

7.7

Good quality reptile food with convenient packaging, but size can vary.

Pros
  • Convenient Packaging
  • Durable
Cons
  • Size Variability
  • Package Damage
Popular Choice
Full Review →
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Rat Pup Frozen Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Rat Pup Frozen Reptile Food

2.1

Not worth the price for undersized rats and broken parts.

Pros
  • Customer Service
Cons
  • Size Consistency
  • Quality
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Hopper Mice Frozen Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Hopper Mice Frozen Reptile Food

8.5

Individually wrapped, clean hopper mice, liked by snakes and reptiles.

Pros
  • Individually Packaged
Cons
  • Packaging Issues
Top Pick
Full Review →
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Medium Rat Frozen Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Medium Rat Frozen Reptile Food

7.0

Good packaging but inconsistent in taste.

Cons
  • Taste Issues
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Jumbo Rat Frozen Reptile Food, 6 count
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Jumbo Rat Frozen Reptile Food, 6 count

10.0

Highly recommended reptile food with great nutrition and perfect prices.

Pros
  • High Quality
Best Choice
Full Review →
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Small Dubia Roaches Live Feed Reptile Food, 1/8 to 1/4-in, 25 count
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Small Dubia Roaches Live Feed Reptile Food, 1/8 to 1/4-in, 25 count

6.6

Highly nutritious but inconsistent quality.

Pros
  • Nutritional Value
  • Packaging Quality
Cons
  • Quality Issues
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Dubia Roaches Live Feed Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Dubia Roaches Live Feed Reptile Food

2.0

Frequent issues with quantity and quality.

Pros
  • Customer Service
Cons
  • Inconsistent Quantity
  • Poor Product Quality
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Fuzzy Rat Frozen Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Fuzzy Rat Frozen Reptile Food

1.0

Total waste of money; size far smaller than labeled

Cons
  • Size Issue
Quality Concerns
Full Review →
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Small Rat Frozen Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Small Rat Frozen Reptile Food

10.0

Frozen reptile food praised for quality and convenience, ideal.

Pros
  • Quality and Freshness
Cons
  • Batch Variation
Nature's Recipe Pure Essentials Limited Ingredient Salmon with Sweet Potato, Green Beans & Brown Rice Recipe in Broth Canned Dog Food
Pet Food

Nature's Recipe Pure Essentials Limited Ingredient Salmon with Sweet Potato, Green Beans & Brown Rice Recipe in Broth Canned Dog Food

8.8

Excellent dog food, loved by most dogs, with great quality and value.

Pros
  • Dogs Love It
  • Great for Allergies
Cons
  • Sauce Amount
  • Hard to Find In Stores
Top Pick
Full Review →
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Hornworm Live Feed Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Hornworm Live Feed Reptile Food

9.2

Highly recommended for reptile diets, particularly for live food enthusiasts.

Pros
  • High Quality
  • Cost-effective
Cons
  • Dead Stock
Quality Pick
Full Review →
Mack's Natural Reptile Food Large Superworms Live Feed Reptile Food
Pet Food

Mack's Natural Reptile Food Large Superworms Live Feed Reptile Food

1.8

Customers report high mortality rates and poor shipping conditions.

Pros
  • None
Cons
  • High Mortality Rates
  • Poor Shipping Conditions
Quality Concerns
Full Review →
Hill's Ideal Balance Grain-Free Natural Salmon & Potato Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food
Pet Food

Hill's Ideal Balance Grain-Free Natural Salmon & Potato Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food

8.8

Cats love this grain-free food, great for sensitive stomachs and shine coats.

Pros
  • Excellent Nutrition
  • Gentle on Stomach
Cons
  • Discontinued Product
  • Adaption Period
Editor's Choice
Full Review →
Hill's Ideal Balance Indoor Natural Chicken & Turkey Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food
Pet Food

Hill's Ideal Balance Indoor Natural Chicken & Turkey Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food

9.0

Highly recommended by cat owners for picky eaters and high-quality ingredients.

Pros
  • Taste
  • Ingredients
Cons
  • Preference Variability
Best Overall
Full Review →
Greenies Smart Topper Duck, Broccoli, Carrots & Barley Recipe Wet Dog Food Topper, 2-oz tray, case of 10
Pet Food

Greenies Smart Topper Duck, Broccoli, Carrots & Barley Recipe Wet Dog Food Topper, 2-oz tray, case of 10

9.9

Dogs love the flavor and it's easy to use.

Pros
  • Great Taste
  • Healthy Addition
Cons
  • Small Size
High Volume, Strong Ratings
Full Review →
Greenies Smart Topper Chicken, Peas, Apples & Brown Rice Recipe Wet Dog Food Topper, 2-oz tray, case of 10
Pet Food

Greenies Smart Topper Chicken, Peas, Apples & Brown Rice Recipe Wet Dog Food Topper, 2-oz tray, case of 10

8.5

Dogs love the taste and smell, great for picky eaters.

Pros
  • Tasty and Smells Great
  • Convenient for Mixing Medication
Cons
  • Peculiar Smell
Greenies Smart Topper Beef, Peas & Carrots Recipe Grain-Free Wet Dog Food Topper, 2-oz tray, case of 10
Pet Food

Greenies Smart Topper Beef, Peas & Carrots Recipe Grain-Free Wet Dog Food Topper, 2-oz tray, case of 10

9.1

Dogs love this topper; picky eaters approved; allergies concern for sensitive pets.

Pros
  • Picky Eater Friendliness
  • Quality Ingredients
Cons
  • Allergic Reactions
  • Ingredient Variability
Allergy Risks
Full Review →
Greenies Smart Topper Chicken with Peas & Duck Variety Pack Wet Dog Food Topper, 2-oz tray, case of 8
Pet Food

Greenies Smart Topper Chicken with Peas & Duck Variety Pack Wet Dog Food Topper, 2-oz tray, case of 8

7.2

Dogs love the flavors, some picky eaters may not enjoy.

Pros
  • Variety of Flavors
  • Easy to Use
Cons
  • Picky Eaters
  • Portion Size
Hill's Ideal Balance Grain-Free Braised Salmon Recipe Canned Cat Food
Pet Food

Hill's Ideal Balance Grain-Free Braised Salmon Recipe Canned Cat Food

3.0

Mixed reception as cats were fussy

Cons
  • Cat Acceptance