Page 2 of 42

Pet Food Reviews (Page 2)

Category: Pet Food
Reset Filters
Whole Earth Farms Grain-Free Chicken & Turkey Recipe Canned Dog Food
Pet Food

Whole Earth Farms Grain-Free Chicken & Turkey Recipe Canned Dog Food

6.8

High-quality ingredients, but packaging issues and mixed reviews.

Pros
  • High-quality ingredients
  • Favorites with dogs
Cons
  • Packaging issues
  • Auto-ship frustrations
Whole Earth Farms Grain-Free Hearty Chicken Stew Canned Dog Food
Pet Food

Whole Earth Farms Grain-Free Hearty Chicken Stew Canned Dog Food

8.4

Dog owners love the quality and taste, but size changes and inconsistent quality are noted.

Pros
  • High-quality ingredients
  • Great taste
Cons
  • Size inconsistency
  • Ingredient changes
Whole Earth Farms Puppy Recipe Dry Dog Food
Pet Food

Whole Earth Farms Puppy Recipe Dry Dog Food

7.5

A good option for puppies with skin issues, but picky eaters may not like it.

Pros
  • Healthy Coat
  • Digestion
Cons
  • Pickiness
  • Allergies
Popular
Full Review →
High Desert Small Animal Feed Alfalfa Hay Small Animal Food
Pet Food

High Desert Small Animal Feed Alfalfa Hay Small Animal Food

8.3

Highly praised by picky small animals, especially bunnies.

Pros
  • Preferred by picky bunnies
  • High acceptance rates
Cons
  • Packaging quality
High Desert Small Animal Feed Orchard Hay Small Animal Food
Pet Food

High Desert Small Animal Feed Orchard Hay Small Animal Food

2.7

Orchard hay with mixed reviews on quality and freshness.

Pros
  • Tasty and Fresh
Cons
  • Dusty and Contaminated
  • Inconsistent Quality
High Desert Small Animal Feed Alfalfa Pellets Small Animal Food
Pet Food

High Desert Small Animal Feed Alfalfa Pellets Small Animal Food

4.2

High-protein alfalfa pellets suitable for many small animals but not for chinchillas.

Pros
  • High Protein
  • Good Ingredients
Cons
  • Not for Chinchillas
  • Digestive Issues
High Desert Small Animal Feed Timothy Hay 1st Crop Small Animal Food
Pet Food

High Desert Small Animal Feed Timothy Hay 1st Crop Small Animal Food

8.0

High-quality hay, but short pieces and dusty.

Pros
  • Quality Hay
Cons
  • Short Pieces
  • Messy
Long pieces over better
Full Review →
High Desert Small Animal Feed Timothy Hay Pellets Small Animal Food
Pet Food

High Desert Small Animal Feed Timothy Hay Pellets Small Animal Food

3.5

Hypoallergenic benefits but picky pets may dislike

Pros
  • Good Taste
  • Beneficial for Food
Cons
  • Selectivity among pets
Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Management Chicken & Vegetables Entree Wet Dog Food
Pet Food

Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Management Chicken & Vegetables Entree Wet Dog Food

4.4

Great for weight management, textural issues reported.

Pros
  • Weight management
  • Taste
Cons
  • Texture Issues
  • Deliver Issues
Quality Concerns
Full Review →
Hill's Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Sensitive Skin Grain-Free Salmon & Vegetable Entree Wet Dog Food
Pet Food

Hill's Science Diet Adult Sensitive Stomach & Sensitive Skin Grain-Free Salmon & Vegetable Entree Wet Dog Food

6.4

Mixed reviews on Hill's Science Diet Dog Food; good for picky eaters but health concerns reported.

Pros
  • Picky Eater Friendly
  • Gentle on Digestion
Cons
  • Health Concerns
  • Allergic Reactions
Pets with sensitive skin
Full Review →
Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Lamb & Potato Entree Canned Dog Food
Pet Food

Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Lamb & Potato Entree Canned Dog Food

5.0

Highly recommended dog food with excellent customer service.

Pros
  • Allergy-Friendly
  • Grain-Free Formula
Cons
  • Low Inventory at Local Stores
Birds LOVE Natural Garden Blend Sunflower-Free Conure Bird Food
Pet Food

Birds LOVE Natural Garden Blend Sunflower-Free Conure Bird Food

8.3

Birds LOVE Garden Blend is a high-quality sunflower-free food, loved by conures and other species, but may be pricey.

Pros
  • High Quality Ingredients
  • Variety of Textures and Flavors
Cons
  • High Price Point
  • Bag Seal Issues
Birds LOVE Natural Garden Blend Medium Parrot Bird Food
Pet Food

Birds LOVE Natural Garden Blend Medium Parrot Bird Food

7.0

BIRDS LOVE is highly recommended by verified purchasers for its functionality and design

Pros
  • Highly Rated
  • Convenient
Cons
  • Pricey
  • Picky Palate
High volume (100+), score ≥7.0
Full Review →
Birds LOVE Natural Garden Blend Large Parrot Bird Food
Pet Food

Birds LOVE Natural Garden Blend Large Parrot Bird Food

7.8

Great bird food mix with some packaging issues, highly recommended for parrots.

Pros
  • Nutritious Content
  • Variety of Ingredients
Cons
  • Packaging Issues
Top Value
Full Review →
Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Salmon Dry Cat Food
Pet Food

Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Salmon Dry Cat Food

4.3

A good grain-free option but some health concerns mentioned.

Pros
  • Cat Acceptance
  • Healthy Appearance
Cons
  • Health Concerns
  • Cost vs Better Options
Quality Concerns
Full Review →
Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Tuna & Vegetable Entree Canned Cat Food
Pet Food

Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Tuna & Vegetable Entree Canned Cat Food

6.5

Mixed reviews on grain-free, minced consistency.

Pros
  • Tuna Flavor
  • Grain-Free Diet
Cons
  • Misleading Labeling
Standlee PremiYum Western Alfalfa Hay Small Animal Food, 12-lb box
Pet Food

Standlee PremiYum Western Alfalfa Hay Small Animal Food, 12-lb box

3.3

Decent alfalfa hay for small animals, but not ideal for picky eaters or indoor use.

Pros
  • Good value
Cons
  • Heavy stems
  • Messy
Standlee PremiYum Western Timothy Hay Small Animal Food
Pet Food

Standlee PremiYum Western Timothy Hay Small Animal Food

6.8

Good quality hay but can be tough and dusty.

Pros
  • Good Quality
  • Value for Money
Cons
  • Too Tough
  • Dusty
Quality Concerns
Full Review →
Solid Gold Surf & Turf Grain-Free Variety Pack Wet Cat Food
Pet Food

Solid Gold Surf & Turf Grain-Free Variety Pack Wet Cat Food

7.6

Solid Gold Surf & Turf is a hit with cats, despite some picky eaters and high cost.

Pros
  • High-Quality Ingredients
  • Variety of Flavors
Cons
  • High Cost
  • Some Cats are Picky
Quality Ingredients
Full Review →
Solid Gold Green Cow Beef Tripe Loaf for Picky Eaters Grain-Free Wet Dog Food, 13.2-oz can, case of 6
Pet Food

Solid Gold Green Cow Beef Tripe Loaf for Picky Eaters Grain-Free Wet Dog Food, 13.2-oz can, case of 6

5.7

Mixed reviews for Solid Gold wet dog food, with concerns about smell and picky eating.

Pros
  • High Nutritional Value
Cons
  • Strong Smell
  • Inconsistent Quality
Declined
Full Review →
Blue Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Variety Pack Adult High Protein Grain-Free Natural Chicken & Turkey, Chicken & Trout, Chicken & Salmon in Tasty Gravy Wet Cat Food, 3-oz can, case of 12
Pet Food

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Wild Delights Variety Pack Adult High Protein Grain-Free Natural Chicken & Turkey, Chicken & Trout, Chicken & Salmon in Tasty Gravy Wet Cat Food, 3-oz can, case of 12

8.4

Cats love the variety and gravy, but some dislike the texture.

Pros
  • Variety of Flavors
  • High Protein and Grain-Free
Cons
  • Texture and Size Issues
  • Strong Odor
Popular Choice
Full Review →
Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Natural Purees Chicken Wet Cat Food, 3-oz pouch, case of 12
Pet Food

Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Natural Purees Chicken Wet Cat Food, 3-oz pouch, case of 12

10.0

Excellent quality and value, highly recommended for cats

Pros
  • Taste
  • Convenient Packaging
Cons
  • Price
Best Overall
Full Review →
Blue Buffalo Wilderness Variety Pack Adult High Protein Natural Chicken, Salmon, Turkey Pate Wet Cat Food
Pet Food

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Variety Pack Adult High Protein Natural Chicken, Salmon, Turkey Pate Wet Cat Food

4.9

Mixed reviews for Blue Buffalo cat food; quality control issues noted.

Pros
  • High Protein
  • Variety of Flavors
Cons
  • Quality Control Issues
  • Inconsistent Flavor Acceptance
Instinct Raw Boost Adult Grain-Free Real Beef Recipe Dry Dog Food
Pet Food

Instinct Raw Boost Adult Grain-Free Real Beef Recipe Dry Dog Food

5.3

Mixed reviews on quality and customer service.

Pros
  • Ingredient Quality
  • Health and Energy
Cons
  • Ingredient Name vs Sensitivity
  • Customer service