Page 12 of 34

Cat Food Reviews (Page 12)

Category: Cat Food
Reset Filters
Sheba Signature Broths Tuna, Shrimp & Crab in Clear Broth Cat Food Topper
Cat Food

Sheba Signature Broths Tuna, Shrimp & Crab in Clear Broth Cat Food Topper

8.2

Highly recommended cat food topper with great taste and texture

Pros
  • Tasty flavor
  • Moisture addition
Cons
  • Pickiness regarding fish
  • Quality Variation
Sheba Signature Broths Tuna, Chicken & Vegetable in Clear Cat Food Topper
Cat Food

Sheba Signature Broths Tuna, Chicken & Vegetable in Clear Cat Food Topper

8.5

Sheba Signature Broths is a hit with finicky cats, offering great taste and texture.

Pros
  • Tasty for Picky Cats
  • High-Quality Ingredients
Cons
  • No Major Complaints
Sheba Signature Broths Clear Broth Variety Pack Cat Food Topper
Cat Food

Sheba Signature Broths Clear Broth Variety Pack Cat Food Topper

7.6

Cats love it, but some picky eaters may not.

Pros
  • Cats Love
  • Variety of Flavour
Cons
  • Cats Didn't Like
  • Expensive
Sheba Perfect Portions Grain-Free Multipack Savory Chicken, Delicate Salmon & Roasted Turkey Pate Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Sheba Perfect Portions Grain-Free Multipack Savory Chicken, Delicate Salmon & Roasted Turkey Pate Cat Food Trays

9.2

Cats love it, easy to ship and order, great for fussy eaters.

Pros
  • Variety of Flavors
  • Perfect Portions
Cons
  • Occasional Leaking
High Volume, Excellent Rating
Full Review →
Meow Mix Simple Servings with Real Chicken & Turkey in Gravy Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Meow Mix Simple Servings with Real Chicken & Turkey in Gravy Cat Food Trays

9.2

Cat owners rave about Meow Mix Simple Servings for finicky cats.

Pros
  • Picky Eater Approval
  • Convenient Packaging
Cons
  • Availability Issues
  • Price and Availability
Customer Favorite
Full Review →
Meow Mix Simple Servings with Real Tuna & Ocean Whitefish in Sauce Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Meow Mix Simple Servings with Real Tuna & Ocean Whitefish in Sauce Cat Food Trays

8.5

Cat owners rave about Meow Mix Simple Servings for its taste and convenience.

Pros
  • Flavor
  • Portion Control
Cons
  • Packaging Issues
  • Production Issues
Top Value
Full Review →
Vital Essentials Freeze-Dried Raw Turkey Mini Patties Entree Cat Food
Cat Food

Vital Essentials Freeze-Dried Raw Turkey Mini Patties Entree Cat Food

6.5

Decent taste, but picky cats might avoid it

Pros
  • Flavor
  • Quality
Cons
  • Pickiness
  • Texture
Vital Essentials Freeze-Dried Raw Duck Mini Patties Entree Cat Food
Cat Food

Vital Essentials Freeze-Dried Raw Duck Mini Patties Entree Cat Food

5.6

Cat food with mixed reviews, quality concerns noted.

Pros
  • Taste Appeal
  • Convenient Serving
Cons
  • Bone Shards
  • Coarse Patties
Quality Concerns
Full Review →
Vital Essentials Freeze-Dried Raw Chicken Entree & Mixer Cat Food Crunchy Nibs
Cat Food

Vital Essentials Freeze-Dried Raw Chicken Entree & Mixer Cat Food Crunchy Nibs

7.2

Most cats enjoy it, but it's pricey and some find it too hard to chew.

Pros
  • Natural Ingredients
  • Taste
Cons
  • High Price
  • Hard to Chew
Triumph Meals of Victory Liver Recipe in Savory Juices Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Triumph Meals of Victory Liver Recipe in Savory Juices Cat Food Trays

7.2

Soft, liver-flavored cat food loved by many, but with mixed reception on taste.

Pros
  • Loved by Cats
  • Convenient Packaging
Cons
  • Picky Cats
  • Texture Issues
Quality Concerns
Full Review →
Triumph Meals of Victory Seafood Medley in Savory Juices Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Triumph Meals of Victory Seafood Medley in Savory Juices Cat Food Trays

3.6

Mixed reviews on taste and texture.

Pros
  • Good Ingredients
  • Acceptable to Some Cats
Cons
  • Texture Issues
  • Lack of Gravy
Declining Expectations
Full Review →
Crave Turkey & Duck Pate Grain-Free Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Crave Turkey & Duck Pate Grain-Free Cat Food Trays

8.0

Most cats love the flavor, but some find it too dry.

Pros
  • Great Flavor
  • Convenient Portions
Cons
  • Texture Issues
  • Packaging Issues
Best in Class
Full Review →
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Turkey Recipe Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Turkey Recipe Cat Food Trays

8.2

Cats love the flavor, but packaging can be tricky.

Pros
  • Flavor
  • Convenient Portions
Cons
  • Packaging Issues
  • Gelatinous Texture
Top Value
Full Review →
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Real Salmon & Shrimp Recipe Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Real Salmon & Shrimp Recipe Cat Food Trays

4.2

Good quality cat food, but packaging could be improved.

Pros
  • Taste
  • Value
Cons
  • Packaging
  • Picky Eaters
ORIJEN Original Chunks & Shreds Variety Pack Duck & Liver Wet Cat Food
Cat Food

ORIJEN Original Chunks & Shreds Variety Pack Duck & Liver Wet Cat Food

7.8

Cats love the variety pack, but some dislike the liver flavor.

Pros
  • Novel proteins
  • Variety of textures
Cons
  • High calorie content
  • Texture issues
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Real Turkey & Real Chicken Cuts in Gravy Recipe Variety Pack Adult Wet Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Real Turkey & Real Chicken Cuts in Gravy Recipe Variety Pack Adult Wet Cat Food Trays

5.5

Cats love it, but packaging and formula issues persist.

Pros
  • Cats Love the Flavor
  • Variety Pack
Cons
  • Problematic packaging
  • Formula changes
Quality Concerns
Full Review →
Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Multi-Pack Real Tuna, Real Salmon & Shrimp Recipe Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Nutro Perfect Portions Grain-Free Cuts in Gravy Multi-Pack Real Tuna, Real Salmon & Shrimp Recipe Cat Food Trays

7.3

Nutro cat food is great but could be easier to open.

Pros
  • High palatability
  • Healthy ingredients
Cons
  • Difficult to open packaging
  • Small portions for larger cats
Satisfactory
Full Review →
Purina Fancy Feast Grilled Feast & Medleys Seafood Collection Wet Cat Food Variety Pack
Cat Food

Purina Fancy Feast Grilled Feast & Medleys Seafood Collection Wet Cat Food Variety Pack

8.4

Highly recommended for cats who love seafood variety.

Pros
  • Great Variety
  • High Quality
Cons
  • Pickiness Issue
  • Allergies Concerns
Great variety and quality for cats, functional against many fads.
Full Review →
I and Love and You Variety Pack Wholly Cow!, Savory Salmon and Purrky Turkey Pate Canned Cat Food
Cat Food

I and Love and You Variety Pack Wholly Cow!, Savory Salmon and Purrky Turkey Pate Canned Cat Food

7.5

Mixed reviews for this variety pack; some cats love it, others are picky.

Pros
  • Moist Texture
  • Pleasant Smell
Cons
  • Beef Flavor
  • Surfeit of Turkey
Volume of reviews and good score
Full Review →
Wild Frontier Indoor Adult Open Valley Recipe Chicken Flavor High-Protein Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
Cat Food

Wild Frontier Indoor Adult Open Valley Recipe Chicken Flavor High-Protein Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

8.2

Highly recommended for fussy eaters and health-conscious cat owners

Pros
  • Accepted by fussy cats
  • High protein content
Cons
  • Regurgitation
  • Leaves cats feeling hungry
Best Overall
Full Review →
Nutro Wild Frontier Real Chicken Recipe Pate Adult High-Protein Grain-Free Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Nutro Wild Frontier Real Chicken Recipe Pate Adult High-Protein Grain-Free Cat Food Trays

5.2

Nutro Wild Frontier has mixed reviews, with cats either loving it or refusing to eat.

Pros
  • Tasty to some
Cons
  • Expensive
Nutro Wild Frontier Real Salmon Recipe Pate Adult High-Protein Grain-Free Cat Food Trays
Cat Food

Nutro Wild Frontier Real Salmon Recipe Pate Adult High-Protein Grain-Free Cat Food Trays

8.2

High-protein, grain-free cat food praised for quality and taste, but size and price concern.

Pros
  • Cat Acceptance
  • Grain-Free Formulation
Cons
  • Size of Trays
  • High Price
Popular Choice
Full Review →
BFF OMG Seeya Sooner! Chicken & Tuna Dinner in Gravy Grain-Free Cat Food Pouches
Cat Food

BFF OMG Seeya Sooner! Chicken & Tuna Dinner in Gravy Grain-Free Cat Food Pouches

9.5

A favorite among cats, with consistent quality and great taste.

Pros
  • Taste
  • Update hydation
Cons
  • Allergic Reactions
Best Overall
Full Review →
BFF OMG Shazaam! Lamb & Tuna Dinner in Gravy Grain-Free Cat Food Pouches
Cat Food

BFF OMG Shazaam! Lamb & Tuna Dinner in Gravy Grain-Free Cat Food Pouches

8.5

Highly recommended cat food with overwhelming positive feedback.

Pros
  • Tastes Amazing
Cons
  • Some Cats Don't Like It
Editor's Choice
Full Review →