Page 1 of 34

Cat Food Reviews

Category: CAT FOOD
Reset Filters
Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Management Chicken Recipe Dry Cat Food
Cat Food

Hill's Science Diet Adult Perfect Weight Management Chicken Recipe Dry Cat Food

7.9

Good for weight management, but size inconsistency reported.

Pros
  • Effective Weight Management
  • Favored By Cats
Cons
  • Inconsistent Kibble Size
  • Dull Coat After Use
High Volume and Consistent Ratings
Full Review →
Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Trout Entree Canned Cat Food
Cat Food

Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Trout Entree Canned Cat Food

6.9

Grain-free Trout cat food good for picky CKD cats, mixes well with other foods; one cat disliked it.

Pros
  • Suits CKD Cats
  • High in Protein
Cons
  • Unpalatable for Some!
Best Seller
Full Review →
Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Chicken & Vegetable Entree Canned Cat Food
Cat Food

Hill's Science Diet Adult Grain-Free Chicken & Vegetable Entree Canned Cat Food

6.6

Mixed reviews on texture and taste.

Pros
  • Good for coat health
  • High-quality taste
Cons
  • Consistency issues
  • Very Dry
Solid Gold Five Oceans Variety Pack Grain-Free Shreds in Gravy Wet Cat Food
Cat Food

Solid Gold Five Oceans Variety Pack Grain-Free Shreds in Gravy Wet Cat Food

7.5

Generally well-received, some cats refused food, quality good

Pros
  • Quality Ingredients
  • Variety and Flavor
Cons
  • Strong Fish Smell
  • Cat Refusal
Budget pick
Full Review →
Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Natural Purees Tuna Wet Cat Food, 3-oz pouch, case of 12
Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Natural Purees Tuna Wet Cat Food, 3-oz pouch, case of 12

9.5

Cats love the taste and convenience of Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Purees.

Pros
  • Great Taste
  • Convenient Packaging
Cons
  • N/A
Best Overall
Full Review →
Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Natural Purees Salmon Wet Cat Food, 3-oz pouch, case of 12
Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Natural Purees Salmon Wet Cat Food, 3-oz pouch, case of 12

7.7

Most cats love the taste and convenience, but some picky eaters reject it.

Pros
  • Tasty Salmon Flavors
  • Resealable Pouches
Cons
  • Picky Eaters Discrimination
  • Potential Discontinuation
Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Natural Purees Variety Pack Chicken & Tuna Wet Cat Food, 3-oz pouch, case of 12
Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Adult Natural Purees Variety Pack Chicken & Tuna Wet Cat Food, 3-oz pouch, case of 12

4.1

Mixed reviews on taste and texture; good for hiding meds.

Pros
  • Pale Puree Texture
  • Medication Mixing
Cons
  • Dry Texture
  • Flip Mark
Friskies Seafood Favorites Variety Pack Lickable Gravy Cat Food Complement, 1.5-oz pouch, case of 24
Cat Food

Friskies Seafood Favorites Variety Pack Lickable Gravy Cat Food Complement, 1.5-oz pouch, case of 24

2.9

Cats generally dislike the gravy flavor in this variety pack.

Pros
  • Variety of Flavors
  • Shakes Preferred
Cons
  • Gravy Flavor Disliked
  • Price Not Worth It
Friskies Poultry Favorites Variety Pack Lickable Gravy Cat Food Complement
Cat Food

Friskies Poultry Favorites Variety Pack Lickable Gravy Cat Food Complement

2.9

Friskies gravy cat food receives mixed reviews.

Pros
  • Gravy preferred
  • Variety pack
Cons
  • Large food pieces
  • Packaging issues
Hill's Ideal Balance Hairball Natural Chicken & Barley Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food
Cat Food

Hill's Ideal Balance Hairball Natural Chicken & Barley Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food

8.9

Cats love Hill's Ideal Balance for improved skin and hair, zero hairballs.

Pros
  • Eliminates Hairballs
  • Healthy Skin and Fur
Cons
  • Hard to Find in Stores
Editor's Choice cats
Full Review →
Hill's Ideal Balance Slim & Healthy Natural Chicken & Peas Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food
Cat Food

Hill's Ideal Balance Slim & Healthy Natural Chicken & Peas Recipe Adult Dry Cat Food

9.5

Highly recommended for healthy and active cats.

Pros
  • Quality Ingredients
  • Cat Appeal
Best Overall
Full Review →
ACANA Indoor Cat Highest Protein Dry Cat Food
Cat Food

ACANA Indoor Cat Highest Protein Dry Cat Food

8.3

ACANA Indoor Cat food is great for high protein and shiny coats.

Pros
  • High Protein Content
  • Variety of Flavors
Cons
  • Allergic Reactions
  • Smell
Nature's Recipe Grain-Free Whitefish & Crab Recipe in Broth Wet Cat Food
Cat Food

Nature's Recipe Grain-Free Whitefish & Crab Recipe in Broth Wet Cat Food

3.5

Mixed reception among cat owners with varied opinions on taste and acceptance.

Pros
  • Variety
Cons
  • Taste Acceptance
average
Full Review →
Nature's Recipe Grain-Free Chicken & Chicken Liver Recipe in Broth Wet Cat Food
Cat Food

Nature's Recipe Grain-Free Chicken & Chicken Liver Recipe in Broth Wet Cat Food

6.7

Most cats love it, but finicky eaters may reject it.

Pros
  • High-Quality Ingredients
  • Easy to Feed
Cons
  • Taste Not Universally Loved
  • Pricy
Weruva Cats in the Kitchen Word From The Bird Variety Pack Wet Cat Food, 6.0-oz can, case of 12
Cat Food

Weruva Cats in the Kitchen Word From The Bird Variety Pack Wet Cat Food, 6.0-oz can, case of 12

7.9

A highly rated cat food with a variety of flavors that most cats love.

Pros
  • Variety of Flavors
  • High Moisture Content
Cons
  • Dietary Sensitivity
  • Varied Interest in Flavors
All three cats enjoyed this variety pack
Full Review →
BFF Kitten Pawsome Purrs Wet Cat Food, 2.8-oz can, case of 12
Cat Food

BFF Kitten Pawsome Purrs Wet Cat Food, 2.8-oz can, case of 12

9.0

High-quality cat food loved by kittens and their owners

Pros
  • Delicious taste
  • Good for digestive health
Cons
  • Picky eaters
  • Fishy smell
Wellness Complete Health Indoor Health Salmon & Whitefish Meal Recipe Dry Cat Food
Cat Food

Wellness Complete Health Indoor Health Salmon & Whitefish Meal Recipe Dry Cat Food

6.8

High-quality cat food with mixed reviews on palatability and packaging issues.

Pros
  • High-Quality Ingredients
  • Health Benefits
Cons
  • Packaging Issues
  • Price
Quality Concerns
Full Review →
Blue Buffalo Freedom Indoor Adult Fish Recipe Grain-Free Canned Cat Food
Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Freedom Indoor Adult Fish Recipe Grain-Free Canned Cat Food

7.1

A generally loved cat food with minor issues

Pros
  • Great Nutritional Value
  • Good Texture
Cons
  • Aroma Concerns
  • Texture Issues
Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Pate Chicken Entree Indoor Adult Canned Cat Food
Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Healthy Gourmet Pate Chicken Entree Indoor Adult Canned Cat Food

7.2

Mixed reviews on new formula; some cats love it, others hate it.

Pros
  • Excellent for sensitive stomachs
  • Highly recommended
Cons
  • Digestive Issues
  • Changed formula
Blue Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe with Trout Adult Grain-Free Dry Cat Food
Cat Food

Blue Buffalo Wilderness Rocky Mountain Recipe with Trout Adult Grain-Free Dry Cat Food

7.1

A solid choice for picky cats, with some flavor variability.

Pros
  • High-quality ingredients
  • Good for picky eaters
Cons
  • Flavor issues
  • Quality of ingredients
Glowing Skin
Full Review →
Fancy Feast Medleys Tender Turkey Primavera Canned Cat Food
Cat Food

Fancy Feast Medleys Tender Turkey Primavera Canned Cat Food

7.2

A good wet food choice for cats that like fresh flavors.

Pros
  • Flavor and Texture
  • Health and Coat Quality
Cons
  • Texture Changes
Editor's Tip
Full Review →
Fancy Feast Medleys Wild Salmon Primavera Canned Cat Food
Cat Food

Fancy Feast Medleys Wild Salmon Primavera Canned Cat Food

6.8

Most cats love this food, but beware of inconsistent availability and quality issues.

Pros
  • Palatable to Cats
  • Healthy Ingredients
Cons
  • Potential Waste
  • Availability Issues
Quality Concern
Full Review →
Fancy Feast Medleys Tuna Primavera Canned Cat Food
Cat Food

Fancy Feast Medleys Tuna Primavera Canned Cat Food

5.2

Mixed reviews on consistency and taste.

Pros
  • Taste and Variety
  • Consistency
Cons
  • Inconsistent Shred Size
  • Formula Changes
Fancy Feast Medleys Shredded Wild Salmon Fare Canned Cat Food
Cat Food

Fancy Feast Medleys Shredded Wild Salmon Fare Canned Cat Food

7.5

A popular choice among cats, but picky eaters may not like it.

Pros
  • Taste and Variety
  • Availability through Chewy
Cons
  • Picky Eaters
  • Occasional Reliability Issues