Redbarn Air Dried Fish Training Dog Treats, 4.75-oz bag
In a Nutshell
- Main issue: Treats crumble easily
- Liked: Fish flavor and simple ingredients
- Recommended for: Dogs who like fish flavor and nonsensitive stomachs
- Function: Mixed feedback but works as kibble topper.
Quick Verdict
The treats are convenient in size for dogs and have a good value in flavor. However, the crumbly nature reduces their usability significantly.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Fish Flavor (2)
Many dogs love the fish flavor.
-
Simple Ingredients (1)
Simple ingredients appeal to health-conscious owners.
-
Good Value (2)
Good price-to-quality ratio for those who can work around the crumbling issue.
Cons
-
Crumbling (7) critical
Treats crumble easily making them hard to use as intended.
Tip: Using as a kibble topper.
-
Disappointing Quality (3) major
The product's quality does not meet expectations for use as a treat.
-
Consistency Problems (1) major
Variation in the quality of the treats.
Quality Trend: Declining
Mention of older products being acceptable vs recent issues with consistency.
positive
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Health-conscious dog owners — Because of the simple ingredient list.
✗ Skip If
- • Those expecting robust treats for training — Due to the crumbling issue, not suitable for training.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
The smell of the treat
Ripe and foul.
Would I buy again?
Check the flexibility
Size of the product.
Perfect size.
Highlighted Reviews
""
"I have an obligation to report this baw 4 doctors."
Bottom Line
Despite having a fish flavor that dogs love and simple ingredients that appeal to owners, the significant crumbling issues outweigh the benefits making it a hard pass for manageable daily use.