Dr. Pol Incredi-Pol Favorites Lamb & Brown Rice Dog Food, 24-lb bag
In a Nutshell
- Mixed reception with taste preferences varying among dogs
- Repeated quality issues with rancid batches and strong odors
- Customer service responsive but multiple replacements needed
- Adequate for health with no definitive benefits visible
Quick Verdict
Dr. Pol Lamb & Brown Rice Dog Food has a mixed reception. While some dogs enjoy the taste, there are significant quality concerns with rancid batches and strong odors. Customer service is praised for quick replacements, but repeated issues have led to customer dissatisfaction.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Rancid batches
Prevention: Inspect bag upon arrival.
Pros & Cons
Pros
Cons
-
Rancid Batches and Strong Odors (2) major
Multiple users reported receiving rancid batches that were rejected by their dogs.
-
Unpleasant Odors (2)
Strong and unpleasant odors are frequently mentioned making food unpalatable
-
Nuggets Too Small (1) minor
Some dogs had difficulty eating the small kibble, leading to choking issues.
Quality Trend: Declining
Users report increasing issues with rancid batches and food becoming inedible for dogs.
neutral
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of Dogs Who Are Sensitive to Odors — The strong and unpleasant odors reported can make the food unappetizing and unusable for such dogs.
Durability & Care
Factors: batch variation, storage, exposure to air
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Store in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight.
- 💡 Use within 6 months of opening.
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Does this dog food cause choking hazards?.
Yes, some reviewers reported minor choking issues due to the small size of the kibbles, especially in larger dogs.
How does this food smell?
The food has a strong odor, which some dogs find unappetizing and other dogs can eat without issues.
What is the most common issue with this dog food?
The most common issue reported is the strong odor that makes the food inedible for dogs.
Highlighted Reviews
"My dogs are eating the Dr Pol dry food better than the kinds we have used in the past"
"I fed Dr. Pol's Lamb and Rice a few times. Then about my 4th order the kibbles were so odorous the dogs wouldn't touch it. Chewy was outstanding. They tried and sent me three times brand new bags different lot numbers. All with same problem, before a full refund. I love lamb myself and am aware that..."
Bottom Line
If you're considering this food, be prepared for potential quality issues and strong odors. It may be worthwhile to try a smaller bag first to gauge your dog's reaction.