Brown's Extreme! Botanical Small Pet Hay, 24-oz bag
In a Nutshell
- Highly recommended for picky eaters.
- Quality inconsistencies reported.
- Added forage provides enrichment.
Quick Verdict
Brown's Extreme Botanical Small Pet Hay is a good choice for picky eaters, featuring fresh hay and added forage. However, there are some quality control issues reported.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
health concerns leading to pet euthanasia
Prevention: Monitor your pet closely when introducing this hay.
dried out and cheap
Prevention: Inspect the hay for freshness before purchasing.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Enrichment and Dinner (2)
Provides both mental stimulation and nutrition for pets.
-
Fresh and Green (3)
The hay is consistently fresh and green.
-
Good Smell (2)
The hay has a pleasant smell that pets and owners like.
-
Variety and Fresh (1)
The hay is fresh and contains various forages and flowers.
Cons
-
Dried Out and Cheap (1) major
Some users reported the hay being too dry and of poor quality.
-
Health Concerns (1) critical
There are serious health concerns reported, including pet deaths.
-
Quality Inconsistency (1) major
Quality control issues reported by users.
-
Not Thought (1) major
Sometimes the barn was not wet
Quality Trend: Declining
Some users reported the hay being dry and cheap.
positive
mixed
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • owners of picky eaters — the added forage and freshness keeps pets engaged and well-fed
✗ Skip If
- • owners concerned about quality inconsistencies — there are reported issues with dryness and health concerns
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
is you hay come with forage
This hay is the best option.
Highlighted Reviews
"My bun, Yoko, is extremely picky. You would think she was royalty. This is always fresh, green and has added forage, so it keeps her busy and fed. Enrichment and dinner all in one. What’s not to love?"
"This is the worst product I’ve ever purchased. Tried it once but it was awful, pets did not like it."
Bottom Line
While most pets love this hay, quality inconsistencies are a concern. Ensure you check the freshness before purchasing and monitor your pet's reaction.