Redbarn Whole Deer Antler Dog Chews
In a Nutshell
- Generally liked by smaller dogs.
- Frequent complaints about small size and lack of durability.
- Price concerns and worry about the risk of ingestion.
Quick Verdict
These antler chews are generally liked by dogs but frequently criticized for being too small and not durable enough. Several users reported that the size was much smaller than expected for the price.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Risk of choking for small dogs.
Prevention: Use under supervision and ensure size is appropriate.
Potential ingestion of smaller pieces.
Prevention: Monitor while dog is chewing.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Durable for some dogs (2)
Chews can last a long time for some dogs.
-
Affordable (1)
Offered at a fair price point for a chew toy.
-
Hard to destroy (1)
Hard and durable, but still enjoyable to chew for dogs.
Cons
-
Overly small (4) critical
Product size is disappointing compared to customer expectation from pictures/
Tip: Checking size before buying.
-
Value for the price (3) major
Generally too expensive for the size.
-
Dogs getting easily bored/injured (3) major
Some dogs get tired of the chew quickly or chew too much off at once.
Quality Trend: Declining
Several recent reviews mention declining quality and size inconsistencies.
positive
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Small to medium sized dogs — Provides enough chewing enjoyment.
✗ Skip If
- • Large dogs or strong chewers. — not sturdy enough and may be swallowed.
Durability & Care
Factors: size of the dog, chewing intensity
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this product suitable for large dogs?
No, the size and durability are not suitable for large dogs.
How long do these antlers last?
They typically last 1-3 days depending on the dog's size and chewing intensity.
Are these antlers safe for dogs?
There is a risk of choking and ingestion, especially for smaller dogs.
Is the size accurate?
No, many users report the size is much smaller than expected.
Highlighted Reviews
"Keona is enjoying chewing on this throughout the days. We Love Chewy"
"First time I ordered they were of good-sized these were so little I was almost afraid to give to the dog in fact I haven't given it to the dog I'm afraid she'll choke they're so small"
Bottom Line
If you have a small or moderately sized dog and are looking for an inexpensive chew toy, these antlers might be worth trying. However, if you have a larger or more aggressive chewer, you may want to consider a different option.