Redbarn Naturals Salmon Grain-Free Canned Cat Food
In a Nutshell
- Inconsistent quality reported by multiple users.
- Some cats love the food, others find it lacking.
- Value for money is decent, but not enough to offset quality issues.
Quick Verdict
Redbarn Naturals Salmon Grain-Free Canned Cat Food receives mixed reviews. While some cats love it, others find the quality inconsistent and the product lacking in meat.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Consistent quality issues reported, including less meat and more gravy.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Picky Eaters (3)
Some cats, especially picky eaters, enjoy this food.
-
Grain-Free (2)
The food is grain-free, which is beneficial for cats with grain allergies.
-
Good Value (2)
Some users find the price acceptable for the quality.
Cons
-
Inconsistent Quality (5) critical
Many users report inconsistencies in the product's quality, with some cans having more gravy and less meat.
-
Lack of Meat (4) major
Some cans have significantly less meat than expected.
-
Strong Gravy (3) minor
The product has a strong gravy flavor that some cats dislike.
Quality Trend: Declining
Several reviews mention a decline in quality, with less meat and more gravy in recent cans.
mixed with a more positive slant
negative and disappointed
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cats with grain-free diets — This food is grain-free and suitable for cats with grain allergies.
- • Owners looking for wet cat food — The product is explicitly labeled as wet cat food.
✗ Skip If
- • Cats who dislike strong gravy flavors — The product has a strong gravy flavor that some cats dislike.
- • Owners seeking consistent quality — There are significant quality control issues with this product.
Durability & Care
Factors: Consistent quantity and quality of meat, Cat's preference for the food
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this food good for finicky cats?
Some finicky cats enjoy this food, but there are quality inconsistencies.
What is the shelf life of this food?
Several reviews mention texture changes around 1.5 to 2 months.
Highlighted Reviews
"I did my research, and RedBarn naturals salmon stew met some pretty tough criteria. I appreciate that when I open the can, I don't gag - it smells like real food and my cat absolutely loves it. I wish the cats were just a little bigger as vets tend to encourage 3 ounces of wet food a day and cans ar..."
"Just like the review below said, the first case was great. My cat loved it. The 2nd case was terrible. Not as much meat and different ingredients. The same name though, Salmon Stew. This food smells terrible and looks watery. My cat smells it and walks away. She won't eat it."
Bottom Line
This product is suitable for cats who are picky eaters and enjoy the salmon flavor. However, due to the reported inconsistencies in quality and content, it may not be the best long-term choice. Consider looking for alternatives or buying in smaller quantities to monitor consistency.