Cat Food remarkable Trending Down
Evanger's Grain-Free Hand Packed Catch of the Day Canned Cat Food

Evanger's Grain-Free Hand Packed Catch of the Day Canned Cat Food

By Evanger's 8 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
6.5 /10
Quality
7.3
Value
6.2
Design
0.0
Function
6.8
Durability
6.5

In a Nutshell

  • Quality ingredients
  • Cat acceptance variable
  • Mixed quality feedback
  • Watch out for batch variations
  • Good option for dietary-sensitive cats

Quick Verdict

Evanger's Canned Cat Food is praised for its ingredients but inconsistent quality has affected its appeal. Most cats enjoy the taste, but some have rejected it.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 8
Would Recommend 38%
Would Buy Again 25%
Avg Lifespan 1 years to incur 50% failure

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Caution
🐈 Cats
Suitable

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • High Quality (4)

    The cat food is made with whole, uncut sardines and is grain-free.

  • Natural and Unprocessed (2)

    Much like unprocessed food, highly natural

  • High Water Content (2)

    Helps in keeping cats hydrated

Cons

  • Inconsistent Quality (5) major

    Product quality seems to vary, particularly with the balance between water and fish.

  • Price Concern (3) major

    Perceived as expensive

  • Smell Issues (2) minor

    The smell is difficult to tolerate for humans

  • Uncertain Durations (2) major

    Some pets don't take to food durably

Quality Trend: Declining

No change in formulation but different batches.

Older Reviews Said:

neutral

Newer Reviews Say:

negative

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Cat owners with healthy cats — The high quality and natural ingredients are beneficial for cats with healthy mechanisms.
  • Owners with finicky eaters — Effective for raising finicky eaters

Skip If

  • Owners concerned about price — Pricier for barely edible.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan 3 months to indefinite

Factors: different batches, repeated curing with instructions

Rating Distribution

3.5
8 reviews
5★
38%
4★
13%
3★
25%
2★
25%
1★
0%
high-quality (6) whole sardines (2) natural (2) cold (2) pricey (8) strong smell (2)

Common Questions

How long can this product be stored?

Stored in lowest part of fridge, refrigeration preferred within a month maximising upto 3 months.

Is the product safe for cats with dietary restrictions?

Yes, contains sardines only.

Highlighted Reviews

— Renee

"These contain whole uncut sardines that have been gutted, just like it says on the can and the in the product info. Each of the two cans I've opened so far has contained two whole sardines each, so the fish are on the large size for sardines. "

— StacyH

"a few bites here or there, but the food is not readily consumed. More of a bug off stomach kind of attitude from the cats"

Bottom Line

Potential with inconsistencies means buy carefully.

6.5 /10
Good