Newman's Own Organic Grain-Free 95% Turkey Dinner Canned Cat Food
In a Nutshell
- Organic and contains beneficial broth.
- Most cats refuse to eat it.
- Some cats enjoy the turkey flavor and broth.
- Underfilled cans reported by some users.
- No longer made in the USA, which is a concern for some buyers.
- Certain cats seem to enjoy it, especially those that prefer pate with a broth.
Quick Verdict
Newman's Own Organic Grain-Free 95% Turkey Dinner Canned Cat Food receives mixed reviews. While some cats enjoy it, many reject it, and there are concerns about underfilled cans.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Cats refuse to eat the food.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Organic Ingredients (2)
The food contains organic ingredients.
-
Prefer the Turkey (2)
The turkey flavor is well-received by some cats.
-
BPA-Free Can (1)
The can appears to be BPA-free.
Cons
-
Underfilled Cans (1) major
Cans are reported to be underfilled.
-
Not Made in the USA (1) minor
The product is no longer made in the USA.
-
Cats Refuse Food (7) critical
Cats do not like the food, leaving it untouched.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cats that prefer pate-style food with broth — This product seems to cater to cats that enjoy pate-style food with a good broth.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners looking for a universally liked cat food — Many cats refuse to eat this food, making it a risky choice.
Durability & Care
Factors: usage frequency, portion size
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this food suitable for all cats?
No, many cats refuse to eat it. It may be suitable for cats that prefer pate-style food with a good broth.
Is the can BPA-free?
Highlighted Reviews
"My two cats (9 and 16 years) prefer pate. I think they prefer the turkey but they will eat the chicken as well. What they both like is the broth. Pate is soft with broth and not hard and dry. A winner!"
"My cats will not eat this food at all. I have old cats and young cats, they won't eat it."
Bottom Line
If your cat prefers pate-style food with a good broth, this might be a hit. However, for most cats, this product is likely to be disappointment, especially given the quality concerns and potential issues with underfilled cans.