Newman's Own Organic Grain-Free 95% Chicken & Liver Dinner Canned Cat Food
In a Nutshell
- Mixed reviews on taste acceptance by cats
- Organic ingredients and pate consistency are praised by some
- High price point and picky eaters' aversion are concerns
Quick Verdict
The Newman's Own Organic Grain-Free 95% Chicken & Liver Dinner Canned Cat Food receives mixed reviews. While some cats thoroughly enjoy this food, others completely refuse to eat it. The organic ingredients and pate consistency are appreciated by those who like it, but the high price and picky eaters' aversion are noted drawbacks.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Picky eaters refusing the food
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Organic Ingredients (4)
Many cats love the organic and grain-free formula.
-
Pate Consistency (3)
The pate consistency is appreciated by many cat owners.
Cons
-
Picky Eaters (5) critical
Many cats refuse to eat this food, especially picky ones.
-
Price Point (3) major
The high price is a concern for some buyers.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cat owners with non-picky eaters — Cats who enjoy the taste and texture of this organic food.
✗ Skip If
- • Cat owners with picky eaters — Many cats refuse to eat this food, making it a poor choice for finicky cats.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Use it in conjunction with other foods or treats if cats seem reluctant.
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this food suitable for picky eaters?
No, many cats refuse to eat this food, making it a poor choice for picky eaters.
Is the price worth it for this food?
The price is considered fair by some but high by others, especially if their cats refuse to eat it.
What is the consistency of this food?
The food has a pate consistency with a thick but not overwhelming gravy.
Highlighted Reviews
"My very finicky cats eat this! It has a nice, pate consistency, a thick nice gravy but not too much gravy, does not smell to high heaven & cleans up out of the empty can easily. I like that it is no nonsense & organic and the size is perfect for two cats when split half & half."
"Neither of 2 will even consider this food. No a single bite. Very disappointed, bought 24 cans."
Bottom Line
Consider this product if you have cats who enjoy organic, high-quality food and aren't too picky. However, be prepared for the possibility that your cat might not like it, and factor in the higher cost before purchasing.