Newman's Own Organic Grain-Free 95% Chicken Dinner Canned Cat Food
In a Nutshell
- Mix of opinions, with some cats liking the food but many buyers hating the smell.
- Frequent reports of bad batches and rancid odors.
- Quality and consistency are significant concerns.
Quick Verdict
While some cats enjoy the taste, many reviews report a horrible smell and bad batches. Quality issues are frequent.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Many bad batches reported with a putrid smell and cats refusing to eat. Several mentions of 'worse than before.'
Prevention: Verify batch freshness before purchase; consider smaller sizes for initial sampling.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Chicken Dinner (2)
Some cats definitely love the chicken flavor. Buyers
Cons
-
Unpleasant Smell (6) critical
The most significant complaint is the unpleasant and sometimes rancid smell of the food.
Quality Trend: Declining
Recent reviews report a significant decline in quality, with many mentioning bad batches and strong odors.
mixed
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Pet owners with fussy cats — The product is suitable for cats that enjoy a smooth texture with meat flavor.
✗ Skip If
- • Pet owners sensitive to smells — Many users have reported an awful smell, which might be a turn-off.
Durability & Care
Rating Distribution
Bottom Line
Due to quality issues and frequent complaints about the smell, this product is not strongly recommended. Potential buyers should exercise caution and consider trying a smaller batch first.