Bocce's Bakery Feast of Fishies Soft & Chewy Cat Treats, 2-oz bag
In a Nutshell
- Highly divisive among cats: loved by some, detested by others.
- Texture and smell are common complaints.
- Consider testing a small amount before purchasing a full bag.
Quick Verdict
Bocce's Bakery Feast of Fishies treats receive mixed reviews. While some cats love them, others find them unappealing due to texture and smell.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Great for Picky Eaters (2)
This treat appeals to cats with particular tastes.
-
High Appeal (2)
Cats beg for these treats.
-
Gift Worthy (1)
Great for cat lovers as gifts.
Cons
-
Texture Issues (2) major
Many cats find the treats too hard, one cat got hard and dry.
Tip: possibly softer in a different season or with more time allowed
-
Unpalatable Smell (1) major
Some cats reject the treats due to an unappealing smell.
Tip: smell preference is inherent and cannot be fixed.
-
Not a Treats for Animals with IBD (1) major
hardure is an issue when giving mutation biquet and these are hard.
Tip: try other treats that are not hard
-
May Need Validation () medium
For cats who do not consume the treats immediately, additional validation is essential.
Tip: try other
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cat owners with picky eaters — These treats appeal to cats with particular tastes.
- • Those looking for gourmet cat treats — The unique flavor may appeal to gourmet-oriented pet owners.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners with cats who dislike fish flavors — The fish flavor may be unappealing to some cats.
- • Those with cats who prefer soft treats — The treats may be too hard for some cats.
Durability & Care
Factors: Texture and packaging
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
How hard are these treats?
The treats are reported as being too hard for some cats, making them difficult to chew or eat.
Do these treats have a strong smell?
Yes, some reviewers mentioned a neutral grain smell that may be off-putting to cats.
Highlighted Reviews
"Our cat had some and I got more to give to our local no-kill shelter"
"Came as part of Chewy Goody Box. Bengal cat, who is not a picky eater, would not entertain eating these. They just got slapped around until I had to pick them up and throw them away. Texture is hard and has a very neutral grain smell. Not recommended."
Bottom Line
For cats who love these treats, they are a delight. For those who don't, they may end up unclaimed. Consider offering a small amount first to gauge your cat's interest.