this and that Canine Company Sydney's Harbour Small Fish Planks Dehydrated Cat & Dog Treat, 2.5-oz bag
In a Nutshell
- Mixed reviews on cat and dog treat.
- Large pieces may be difficult for cats to eat.
- valuation varies depending on pet species.
Quick Verdict
The reviews for this product are mixed, with some pets, particularly cats showing no interest in the treats. However, some cat owners and dog owners found it to be a useful treat.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
will not be able to swallow whole planks without chewing
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Dehydrated Fish (1)
The design with dehydrated fish enhances treat palatability.
-
Durability (1)
One user found the package to last for a considerable time.
-
Novelty (1)
The treat introduces a new and different treat for dogs.
-
Value for Money (1)
Good value as durable and long lasting.
-
High Quality Materials (1)
High quality fish snack.
Cons
-
Size (3) critical
The large pieces are too hard for cats to eat.
-
Silverfish smell (1) medium
The smell of fish can be considered by some as inedible
-
Large Hard Pieces (1) minor
The large pieces of the snack make it unfit.
-
Market Misleading (1) major
The product is being represented as drool worthy when it is not. The customers are trickled due to mismarketing
-
Deceptive Marketing (1) major
Product provides incorrect information about the products that mislead the users.
-
Not for Whiskers (1) critical
The snacks are more suitable for dogs than for cats. The manufacturers must make these snacks specifically for cats or some cats.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog Owners — Dogs might find the fishy treats to be interesting.
✗ Skip If
- • Cat Owners — may find the treat to be unpalatable.
Durability & Care
Factors: none
Cleaning Methods
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this product suitable for dogs and cats?
It seems to be more palatable for dogs than for cats
What is the ingredient?
fish
Highlighted Reviews
"Large pieces of very hard, dry fish skin. My cats could not even eat a little piece although they liked the smell. Maybe for dogs but not the kitties!!"
Bottom Line
The product is not suitable for everyone, particularly cats, some dogs may enjoy this treat.