I and Love and You XOXO Chicken & Beef Pate Grain-Free Variety Pack Canned Cat Food, 3-oz can, case of 12
In a Nutshell
- Many cats love the taste.
- Texture inconsistencies reported.
- Occasional freshness issues.
Quick Verdict
The I and Love and You XOXO Chicken & Beef Pate Grain-Free Variety Pack is enjoyed by many cats for its taste, but some users report issues with inconsistencies in texture and freshness.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Inconsistent texture and freshness issues
Prevention: Check the expiration date and inspect the can for freshness before purchasing.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Taste and Enjoyment (4)
Cats generally enjoy the flavor of the food.
-
High Quality (2)
The product is praised for its high quality.
Cons
-
Texture Inconsistencies (3) major
Some cans are reported to be watery and not as expected.
-
Freshness Issues (2) critical
Some cans were reported to be rancid or not fresh.
-
Out of Stock Issues (1) major
Frustration with stock management and lack of notice for replacement.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cats who need grain-free diet — The pate, chicken, and beef varieties available with grain-free ingredients.
✗ Skip If
- • Picky eaters or older cats who need softer foods — Several users mentioned inconsistency in the texture of the food.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
How does the texture of this food compare to other pate foods?
Some users reported the texture to be too watery compared to typical pate.
How fresh does the product taste?
Some users reported that some cans were rancid.
Should I check the cans for freshness before using?
To avoid issues, it's always a good idea to check the production date and inspect visually any discrepancies in the texture before opening it
Highlighted Reviews
"sonny, 19 yr old kitty actually eats this.... lol.... half my battle right there!!"
"I've ordered this regularly. The cats love it. But one of my boxes was completely Rancid. Really shocking. Chewy will probably reimburse me when I notify them . . but still I won't order the "I love you brand " anymore."
Bottom Line
While the product has its fans, potential buyers should be aware of the inconsistent texture and occasional freshness issues. If your cat enjoys the taste, it might be worth a try, but consider purchasing a smaller pack initially to assess quality.