I and Love and You XOXO Tuna & Egg Stew Grain-Free Canned Cat Food, 3-oz can, case of 24
In a Nutshell
- Cats have mixed reactions to the taste and smell.
- Some cats love it, others refuse to eat it.
- Price-to-quality ratio is generally fair.
Quick Verdict
The I and Love and You XOXO Tuna & Egg Stew Cat Food receives mixed reviews. Some cats enjoy the taste, while others refuse to eat it. The food is grain-free and comes in a convenient can size, but the inconsistent feedback raises questions about its universal appeal. The price-to-quality ratio is generally considered fair, but the high variance in cat acceptance makes it a risky choice for picky eaters.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Cats not accepting the food, leading to waste.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Tasty for Some Cats (4)
Some cats enjoy the taste and finish their bowls.
-
Convenient Packaging (2)
The can size is convenient and easy to serve.
-
Grain-Free Formula (1)
The food is grain-free, suitable for cats with grain allergies.
Cons
-
Cats Not Favorably Accepted (6) minor
Some cats refuse to eat the food.
-
Expensive for Non-Consumable (4) major
Some users feel it's a waste of money if cats don't eat it.
-
Large Food Pieces (1) minor
The food pieces are larger than expected.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cats who love tuna and eggs — These cats are likely to enjoy the food.
- • Pet owners looking for grain-free options — This food is grain-free and suitable for diet-restricted pets.
✗ Skip If
- • Cats with picky eating habits — The food might not be well-received by picky eaters.
- • Pet owners on a tight budget — The cost might be too high if the cat does not like the food.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this food suitable for grain-sensitive cats?
Yes, this food is grain-free and suitable for grain-sensitive cats.
How do cats react to this food?
Reactions vary. Some cats love it, while others refuse to eat it.
Highlighted Reviews
"My cat is so far not picky and easts almost all the wet foods (except for lamb/vaison). He loves Fintastic Tuna Stew from I and Love and You. This tuna and egg stew had so many bad reviews and the stew had some stronger fishy smell than the FIntastic Stew so I was a bit worried if he would eat it. H..."
"When I first saw this cat food, I assumed it would be a sure-fire winner. After all, my cats love tuna and whenever I would feed them some scrambled eggs, they would devour that. I have 4 formerly feral cats that we've adopted from the outside and brought into the house. They've since become spoi..."
Bottom Line
If your cat loves tuna and eggs, this might be worth a try. However, given the mixed reviews, it’s advisable to start with a smaller quantity or trial size to see if your cat likes it.