Dog Treats Trending Down
Merrick The General Meaty Bone Dog Treats

Merrick The General Meaty Bone Dog Treats

By Merrick 16 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
5.8 /10
Quality
5.0
Value
4.5
Design
5.5
Function
6.0
Durability
4.5

In a Nutshell

  • Durability issues are the primary concern.
  • Many dogs love the flavor and size.
  • Size inconsistencies can be disappointing.

Quick Verdict

Merrick The General Meaty Bone Dog Treats are generally well-received for their size and flavor but have significant durability issues and sizes inconsistencies have noted.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 16
Would Recommend 40%
Would Buy Again 38%
Avg Lifespan 1-2 months

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Suitable
🐈 Cats
Caution

Critical Warnings

critical

Maggots found inside the bone.

Prevention: Check for visible defects and return if any issues are found.

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Large Size (5)

    Many dogs enjoy the large size of the bone.

  • Good Flavor (4)

    The meaty flavor is well-received by most dogs.

  • Long-lasting Entertainment (3)

    The bone keeps dogs busy for extended periods.

  • Digestibility (2)

    The inside of the bone can be eaten by dogs.

  • Enjoyment (3)

    Kept my dogs engaged for a long time, even for 24 hours.

Cons

  • Durability (5) major

    Many bones fell apart quickly or had quality issues.

    Tip: Consider alternatives if durability is a concern.

  • Size Inconsistencies (4) major

    Some bones were much smaller than expected.

    Tip: Buy from verified sellers to avoid size issues.

  • Maggots (1) critical

    One review mentioned finding maggots inside the bone.

  • Material Quality (1) major

    Dog found it too large to consume

    Tip: Choose an alternative if your pet size is smaller.

Quality Trend: Declining

Several older reviews mention good quality, while newer reviews highlight durability and size issues.

Older Reviews Said:

mostly positive

Newer Reviews Say:

mixed to negative

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Owners of large dogs — The size and durability are suitable for larger breeds.

Skip If

  • Owners of small or picky dogs — Size and flavor may not be suitable.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan 1 day to 2+ years

Factors: Dog size, Dog chewing habits, Environment

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Floor Compatibility

Hardwood
Tile
Carpet
Vinyl
Laminate

Rating Distribution

3.0
16 reviews
5★
25%
4★
25%
3★
6%
2★
6%
1★
38%
large size (5) good flavor (4) long-lasting (3) durability issues (5) size inconsistencies (4) maggots (1)

Highlighted Reviews

— TheJoker

"Talk about giving the dog a bone! The dog loved it!"

— MontyLover

"I do not recommend this product. It literally fell apart the second we opened the wrapping."

Bottom Line

Consider alternatives if durability and consistent sizing are important. Ideal for large breeds and those who enjoy long-lasting, flavorful bones.

5.8 /10
Below Average