Free Sample Review Request Kit: Holistic Select Sample Box
In a Nutshell
- Dogs of almost all breeds involved, including picky eaters, enjoyed the taste
- Some users complained about the strong fishy smell
- Variety of samples makes for good value
Quick Verdict
Dogs love Holistic Select for its taste and health benefits, but some owners found the smell strong. Overall, a good choice for dogs who can appreciate both flavor and nutritional value.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Healthy Ingredients (4)
The product is made from ingredients that are healthy for pets.
-
Great Taste (5)
Dogs seem to enjoy the flavor.
Cons
-
Stronger Fishy Smell (3) minor
Some customers complained about the strong smell of the product.
Tip: Good ventilation in the kitchen or closed container.
-
Quality Consistency (1) medium
Users experienced variances in the consistency of the food quality.
Tip: Try a more extended period to assess further.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
✗ Skip If
- • Pet owners sensitive to fish smell — The product has a strong fish smell that can be offensive
- • Owners concerned about quality consistency — Some reviews reported inconsistencies in the product's quality.
Durability & Care
Factors: Storage
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Depending on Flavor
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are the treats healthy for dogs?
Yes, the treats are praised for being healthy and even suitable for dogs with allergies.
What do dogs think about the taste?
Dogs seem to enjoy the taste, even picky eaters.
Is the smell strong?
Some users mentioned a strong fish smell, which might be off-putting to some.
Highlighted Reviews
"My goldendoodle loves these treats!!! I like that they are healthy for him."
Bottom Line
Holistic Select is great for curious dog owners looking to try a healthy brand. However, if the strong fish smell might be an issue, it might be best to consider other brands.