Icelandic+ Capelin Whole Fish Dehydrated Cat Treats, 1.5-oz bag
In a Nutshell
- Highly palatable to cats
- Strong fishy smell
- May be too hard for some cats
- Can help with dental health
- May require cutting into smaller pieces
Quick Verdict
Icelandic+ Capelin Whole Fish Dehydrated Cat Treats are popular among cats for their taste and health benefits. However, the strong smell and large size can be off-putting for some pets and owners.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
The treats can be very hard and cause discomfort or injury to cats' mouths.
The strong smell can linger and transfer to surfaces.
Prevention: Wash hands thoroughly and feed in a well-ventilated area.
Potential choking hazard for small cats if not cut into smaller pieces.
Prevention: Cut treats into smaller pieces for smaller cats.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Tasty to Cats (6)
Most cats enjoy the taste and enthusiastic cracks these treats.
-
Health Benefits (3)
These treats provide nutritional benefits for cats.
-
Versatile Use (2)
Can be used in puzzle toys or as high-value treats.
-
Long-Lasting Bag (1)
A single bag lasts a long time.
Cons
-
Strong Smell (4) major
The treats have a very strong fishy odor.
-
Large Size (2) major
The treats are too big for some cats.
Tip: Cutting the treats into smaller pieces.
-
Hardness (1) critical
The treats are very hard and can cause discomfort.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cats who enjoy fishy treats — Most cats love the taste and health benefits.
- • Owners looking for dental health benefits — These treats can help wear down tartar and promote a glossy coat.
✗ Skip If
- • Cats who dislike strong smells — The strong fishy odor can be overwhelming.
- • Owners with small cats — The treats may be too large and hard for smaller breeds.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are these treats suitable for small cats?
No, the treats are too large and hard for small cats. It is recommended to cut them into smaller pieces.
How do these treats affect a cat's coat?
The treats provide essential oils that help maintain a glossy coat.
Can these treats be used in puzzle toys?
Yes, these treats are a great option for puzzle toys and training sessions.
How long does one bag last?
A single bag lasts a long time, depending on the frequency of use.
Highlighted Reviews
"These very, very smelly little treats are quite popular with my animals... They're a great heart healthy option for putting in a puzzle toy or use as a high value treat during a training session. The only downside is the horrible stench that clings to everything they touch, and transfers easily."
"These whole fish treats are a gimmick. They are many times so hard it will make the cats mouth bleed. Do not buy these for a Cat."
Bottom Line
If you're looking for a healthy treat that most cats love, these are a good choice. Just be prepared for the strong smell and consider cutting the treats into smaller pieces for easier consumption.