Cat-Man-Doo Extra Large Dried Tuna Flakes Cat & Dog Treats
In a Nutshell
- Mixed reviews on taste and texture.
- Good for cats who like fishy treats.
- Some users note quality decline over time.
Quick Verdict
The Cat-Man-Doo Extra Large Dried Tuna Flakes are a hit with some cats but not all. The treats are generally well-received for their fishy smell and taste, but there are concerns about texture and thinning out.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Tasty Treat (4)
Many cats enjoy the taste and smell of the treats.
-
Great Topper (2)
Used effectively as a food topper to encourage eating.
-
Value for Money (2)
Cost-effective for the amount provided.
Cons
-
Texture Issues (4) major
Floats are very thin and can be difficult to handle.
-
Stronger Smell (3) minor
The smell is overpowering for some users and cats.
-
Texture Changes (2) major
Quality and texture seem to have declined over time.
Quality Trend: Declining
Some users report the product feels drier and less fishy smelling in recent batches.
positive
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cat owners with picky eaters — The treats are tasty enough to entice finicky cats to eat.
- • Owners looking to supplement cat diet — A healthy snack option for cats who need more variety.
✗ Skip If
- • Cat owners with sensitive noses — The strong smell can be overpowering.
- • Owners with cats that prefer dense treats — The treats are very thin and may not satisfy some cats.
Durability & Care
Factors: Storage conditions, Frequency of use
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Use within a few months of opening for best quality
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are these treats suitable for dogs?
Yes, they are suitable for both cats and dogs.
How do I store these treats to maintain freshness?
Store in a cool, dry place and try to use within a few months of opening.
Do these treats have a strong smell?
Some users find the smell is quite strong and overpowering.
Highlighted Reviews
"Best flakes ever."
"these flakes are so thin, you can almost read through them. Only one of my five cats ate any of it, & that was only once... wouldn't touch them again. These are also smoked tuna, which isn't stated on the package but the smell is unmistakable."
Bottom Line
If your cat likes fishy treats, these might be a good option. However, if your cat is picky or sensitive to strong smells, you might want to consider other options or test a small amount first.