SquarePet Squarely Natural Lamb Meal & Brown Rice Formula Dry Dog Food
In a Nutshell
- Dogs do not like the rancid smell and taste of this food.
- Mixing with wet food, broth or cheese doesn't help dogs eat it.
- Some batches may not maintain quality.
- Fish Oil and Rancid Sunflower Oil is frowned upon and due to rancid smell.
Quick Verdict
Rancid smell and taste issues are significant concerns with this product, despite potential allergy benefits.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Allergy Friendly (1)
Some reviewers noted that their dogs with allergies did well with this food.
Cons
-
Rancid Smell (5) critical
The rancid smell is a major deterrent for dogs and even humans.
-
Dogs Refuse to Eat (3) major
Many dogs refused to eat the food, even mixed with other foods.
-
Quality Control Issues (3) major
There are concerns about batch or quality control issues.
Tip: Check batch numbers or request fresh bags.
-
Expense (2) critical
The food is expensive and not worth the cost due to the issues mentioned.
Quality Trend: Declining
Multiple reviews indicate a decline in quality, with many mentioning rancid smells and taste issues.
Low negative sentiment
High negative sentiment
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
✗ Skip If
- • Dogs with sensitive noses or picky eaters — There are repeated issues with rancid smell and refusal to eat.
Durability & Care
Factors: Bag opening date
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Train for eating dry pet food?
Yes Rancid smell supposed to train pet to eat? Not Anymore.
Is cheese effective for dogs?
No Difference
Is brouth effective for rats?
No difference
Is mixing advised?
No preclinical advice has been publised as matter of fact.
Highlighted Reviews
"My Maltese moves this food. Delivery was fast so she did not run out."
"It smells like rancid sunflower oil and the dogs don't like it. While switching them to a new food, ants got into the house and went for the new food but wouldn't touch this SquarePet food. You have to wonder, if even ants won't go near it."
Bottom Line
The food has potential, but severe issues with rancid aroma and taste have led to many dogs refusing it, even after owners tried various mixes and flavor enhancements. Potential buyers should be aware of these common issues before purchasing.