Dr. Elsey's cleanprotein Grain-Free Chicken Recipe Wet Cat Food, 3-oz can, case of 18
In a Nutshell
- Recent formula changes led to significant dissatisfaction
- Cats find the new texture and color unappealing
- Company should consider reverting to the original formula
Quick Verdict
Dr. Elsey's cleanprotein wet cat food has seen a sharp decline in quality, with users reporting poor texture and appearance. Some cats liked the old formula, but recent changes have led to negative feedback.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Significant formula changes have led to dissatisfaction and avoidance by cats.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Good Original Recipe (1)
The original formula was appreciated by cats and owners alike.
Cons
-
Poor Texture and Color (2) major
The new formula has a stiff, unappealing texture and color.
-
Formula Change (2) major
The formula change has led to a decline in quality and customer satisfaction.
Quality Trend: Declining
Customers reported significant changes in the texture and color of the food, making it less desirable for cats.
Positive
Negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Owners with cats that enjoyed the original formula — May have nostalgic value or sentiment from the original product
✗ Skip If
- • Those prioritizing quality and texture — Current product quality has sharply declined
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
How has the formula changed?
The new formula has a stiff, unappealing texture and color, which cats find unpalatable. The change is due to new co-packers and manufacturing differences.
Is the new formula better than the old one?
No, the new formula is not as good as the original. Users and cats have reported significant dissatisfaction with the changes.
Highlighted Reviews
"My cats finally found food they all love! I've tried many brands looking for something healthy! Please don't mess with the recipe!"
"I recently had discovered Dr. ELSEY'S wet cat and was thrilled to find a healthy and desirable food for cats from 1-13 years old. As it has been out of stock everywhere, I contacted the company directly to inquire of estimated time it will be back in stock. They graciously sent me a case for my inte..."
Bottom Line
The current formula of Dr. Elsey's wet cat food is not recommended due to its poor texture and color, which cats find unappealing. The company should consider reverting to the original formula to regain customer trust.