Droll Yankees Onyx Clever Clean Magnet Bird Feeder, 18-in
In a Nutshell
- Easy to fill and refill with a flip-top design
- Attracts finches effectively
- Tube may detach from the base, causing significant problems
- Durability issues reported after a few months
- Quality trend declining
Quick Verdict
The Droll Yankees Onyx Clever Clean Magnet Bird Feeder is easy to fill and refill, attracting finches well. However, durability concerns, particularly the tube detaching from the base, are significant issues that detract from its overall value. The product's quality trend has seen a decline, which is concerning for long-term use.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Easy to Fill (2)
Users appreciate the easy-to-fill top design, making refills convenient.
Cons
-
Durability Issues (1) major
The tube detaching from the base has been a significant issue.
Quality Trend: Declining
Users reported declining quality over time, especially with the feeder's tendency to fall apart over usage period.
positive
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Bird Watchers — It attracts finches effectively and holds a significant amount of feed.
✗ Skip If
- • Long-term users — Durability issues, such as components falling apart, make it unreliable for extended periods.
- • Economy Conscious Pets owners — Bird tubes falling apart.
Durability & Care
Factors: Cleaning, use intensity
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
How easy is it to fill and clean the feeder?
The feeder is reported to be very easy to fill and clean due to its design features, such as an easy-to-open lid and a flip-up top.
What problems have users encountered with durability?
Some users have reported that the tube detaches from the base, particularly after a few months of use additional quality issues might still be there but we need more information.
Is this feeder effective in attracting finches?
Yes, users have mentioned that this feeder attracts finches well.
How do reviews perceive the durability from the other products?
negative usually there is no figure or helps to determine if the product is good or not which in the current cases does hurt a lot
Highlighted Reviews
"Easy to fill feeder...definitely attracts the finches! And holds a lot so you don't have to refill it every other day. Easy to refill with the easy open lid"
"The finches just do not like this as much as my other Nyer seed feeders. Also, when I went to clean it the tube detached from the base and I have no idea how to reattach. So it is useless after just a few months. I have yet to contact droll yankee so if they offer a solution for the physical problem..."
Bottom Line
Recommended for short-term use but consider alternative products for long-term durability.