Polkadog Atlantic Silverside Crunchy Whole Fish Dehydrated Dog & Cat Treats, 2.5-oz bag
In a Nutshell
- Dogs love the treats, especially for training
- Cats may refuse due to strong fish smell
- Healthy and suitable for portion control
Quick Verdict
Overall, dogs seem to enjoy these treats, especially for training purposes. The fish smell is strong and may not be suitable for all pets.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Healthy Ingredients (3)
Treats are rich in omega fatty acids and free from additives.
-
Portion Control (2)
Perfect size for training treats.
-
Single Ingredient (2)
Made from a single, natural ingredient.
-
Effective for Training (2)
Works well as a reward during training sessions.
-
Loved by Dogs (5)
Dogs enjoy these treats, even finicky ones.
Cons
-
Fish Odor (4) major
Treats have a strong fish smell, which some pets dislike.
-
Crushed Treats (2) minor
Some users received treats that were crushed in the bag.
Tip: Users could be more careful handling these bags
-
Size issues (1) minor
Odd shaped fish treat
Tip: Consider alternative for small dog treat.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog owners looking for healthy treats — Rich in omega fatty acids and ideal for training.
- • Owners with finicky dogs — Even picky eaters enjoy these treats.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners with cats — Cats may refuse these treats due to the strong fish smell.
Durability & Care
Factors: Storage conditions, Handling
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are these treats suitable for cats?
No, cats may refuse these treats due to the strong fish smell.
Are these treats effective for training?
Yes, many users found them effective for training.
Do these treats have a strong smell?
Yes, the fish smell is pronounced.
Highlighted Reviews
"My dogs love these for training treats! The light seafood smell entices them to listen & the size is perfect for portion control!"
"I originally got these for 2 of my cats who LOVE minnows, but they absolutely refuse to eat these. There is a very potent odor when you open the bag (which is somewhat expected, it's fish), and most of the fish are broken in halves or thirds. My dogs eat them, but they don't really like them. I don'..."
Bottom Line
If you have a dog that loves fish, these treats are a great option. They are healthy, effective for training, and well-received by most dogs. However, be aware of the strong fish smell and the fact that some cats may refuse them.