Crumps' Naturals Traditional Liver Fillets Dog Treats
In a Nutshell
- Natural ingredients, high quality.
- Hard and brittle, causing dental issues and vomiting.
- Good for training due to size and low calorie count but avoid for dogs with sensitive stomachs or teeth.
- Break off smaller pieces for puppies or smaller dogs.
- Beginners might find the treats suitable for their pets jump in.
Quick Verdict
Crumps' Naturals Traditional Liver Fillets Treats are generally liked for their natural ingredients but have issues with hardness and causing digestive problems in some dogs. These treats are suitable for dogs who enjoy a hard treat and for training purposes, but caution is advised for dogs with dental issues or sensitive stomachs.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Digestive distress and vomiting in some dogs, with a few instances of prolonged issues.
Risk of dental fractures due to the hardness of the treats, especially for puppies or dogs with dental issues.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Natural ingredients (3)
The treats are highly praised for their single-ingredient formula and natural composition.
-
High quality (1)
The treats have consistent quality and are reliable for use in treating.
Cons
-
Hard, brittle texture (5) major
The treats are very hard and can be brittle, posing a risk to dogs' teeth.
Tip: Users suggest breaking the treats into smaller pieces to mitigate the risk to dogs' teeth.
-
Digestive issues (3) major
Some dogs experience digestive problems after consuming these treats.
Quality Trend: Declining
More recent reviews report issues with the treats being too hard and causing issues. Older reviews tended to be more positive.
Positive
Neutral/negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog owners looking for natural treats — The natural ingredients and single-ingredient formula make these treats a healthy choice.
- • Owners of dogs who enjoy hard treats — These treats are suitable for dogs that like a chewy challenge.
- • Trainers or owners needing small, low-calorie treats — The treats are small and low in calories, making them ideal for training purposes.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of dogs with dental issues and petite dogs — The treats are too hard that poses a risk for their teeth.
- • Owners of dogs with sensitive digestive systems — The treats can cause gastrointestinal distress.
Durability & Care
Factors: Frequency of use, Storage conditions
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are these treats suitable for small dogs and puppies?
These treats are too hard for small breed dogs, puppies and have reported gastro issues.
Do these treats cause dental issues in dogs?
Yes, the treats are reportedly very hard and brittle, causing discomfort for dogs and resulting in vomiting. So breaking into smaller pieces is suggested.
Are these treats natural and healthy?
Yes, they are made from a single ingredient and do not have preservatives or fillers.
Highlighted Reviews
"I love the clean brand and my puppy loves them. I trust Crumps because of their consistency in high quality treats."
"These are so hard and brittle. I have a small dog, schnauzer, and the first time I gave her just a piece. In the middle if the night I heard her gagging, then vomit. Bits of this treat were evident. The second time I gave her this treat, the same thing. She has always enjoyed natural treats."
Bottom Line
Consider these treats for their natural quality and suitability for training, but be cautious with the hardness which might cause problems and ensure it fits the nutritional needs of your dog.