PetCakes Halloween Cake Kit Cat Treats, 6.6-oz box
In a Nutshell
- Cute and festive, but lacking in taste and appeal for many cats.
- Some cats completely ignored the treats, while others only licked the icing briefly.
- The re-use mold is a nice touch, but the overall quality and value are questionable.
Quick Verdict
The PetCakes Halloween Cake Kit for cats is a fun and festive treat, but it lacks in taste and overall appeal. Many cats showed no interest in the treats, and some users found the smell unpleasant. The mold is reusable, but the overall quality and value are questionable. Those looking for a themed treat might enjoy the kit, but it may not be worth the price for picky eaters.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Reusable Mold (2)
The mold is a nice addition and can be reused for different treat creations.
Cons
-
Little Interest (6) major
Many cats showed little to no interest in the treats.
-
Unpleasant Smell (2) major
The treats and frosting have an unpleasant smell.
-
Poor Execution (3) major
The execution of the heart cakes some reviewers thought
-
Quality Issues (1) minor
Some users reported issues with the quality of the treats.
Quality Trend: Declining
Recent reviews indicate a decline in quality.
neutral
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cat owners looking for a festive treat for their pets — The kit comes with a reusable mold and is easy to make
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of picky cats or those with small pets — Many cats showed little to no interest in the treats, and some users found the smell unpleasant
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is the mold reusable?
Yes, the mold can be reused for different treat creations.
Can I customize the recipe?
Yes, some users mentioned customizing the recipe with different ingredients like cat-sip milk and added proteins.
Is the frosting recommended?
No, several users mentioned that their cats did not like the frosting and it had an unpleasant smell.
Highlighted Reviews
"My cat loved this! Without adjusting the recipe I doubt he would of though. Instead of water I used cat-sip milk. I then added a chicken squeeze up for the batter and a salmon squeeze up for the frosting. After taking photos I mushed it all up for my cat and he ate it all up and wants more!"
"Cute idea.. my cats licked the icing for about one second and never went back. Threw them away :("
Bottom Line
If you're looking for a fun, festive treat to make for your cats this Halloween, the PetCakes Halloween Cake Kit might be worth a try, but be prepared for the possibility that your cats may not enjoy it as much as you might hope. The mold is a nice touch and can be reused for other treats, but the overall quality and value may not justify the cost for picky eaters.