Horse Treats Formula Change Issues Trending Down
Manna Pro Nutrigood FlaxSnax Omega 3 Skin & Coat Baked Horse Treats, 3.2-lb bag

Manna Pro Nutrigood FlaxSnax Omega 3 Skin & Coat Baked Horse Treats, 3.2-lb bag

By Manna Pro 9 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
6.2 /10
Quality
5.5
Value
6.0
Design
5.0
Function
6.0
Durability
4.8

In a Nutshell

  • Mixed reviews due to formula change
  • Some horses love the treats
  • Many horses dislike the new formula
  • Quality and durability concerns
  • Declining trend in ratings

Quick Verdict

The Manna Pro Nutrigood FlaxSnax Omega 3 Skin & Coat Baked Horse Treats received mixed reviews. Some horses love the treats, praising their size, smell, and nutritional benefits. However, many reviewers noted a significant change in the product's formula, leading to a loss of the cinnamon smell and a change in texture that their horses did not like. This has resulted in a declining trend in ratings and sentiment over time, with many users expressing disappointment and urging the company to revert to the original version. Quality issues and durability concerns further complicate the overall reception of the product.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 9
Would Recommend 44%
Would Buy Again 44%
Avg Lifespan not specified

Pet Compatibility

Critical Warnings

critical

Recent dissatisfied horse tolling

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Size and Fit (2)

    The treats are small and fit well in pockets, making them convenient for handling.

  • Nutritional Benefits (2)

    The treats are praised for their nutritional content and healthy ingredients.

  • Horses Enjoy Them (1)

    Some horses enjoy the taste of the treats, making them a satisfying choice for some users.

Cons

  • Formula Change (5) major

    The new formula lacks the cinnamon smell and crunch texture that horses previously enjoyed.

  • Quality Issues (2) medium

    Concerns about the quality and durability have been mentioned, indicating potential issues with the product's longevity.

    Tip: Consider returning the product if dissatisfied.

  • Texture (4) major

    The new texture is less appealing to horses, with some even turning their noses up at the treats.

Quality Trend: Declining

Recent formula changes have led to a decline in the product's quality, with horses rejecting the new version and users expressing frustration over the lack of the original cinnamon-smelling texture.

Older Reviews Said:

positive

Newer Reviews Say:

negative

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Horse owners who prefer traditional, cinnamon-smelling treats. — These users will appreciate the original, beloved version of the treats, if they haven't been affected by the formula change.
  • Horse owners who prioritize nutritional benefits. — The treats offer Omega 3 ingredients and other beneficial components.

Skip If

  • Horse owners seeking consistency in their horse's treats. — The formula change has led to a significant difference in horse acceptance and may cause frustration for horse owners.
  • Owners of horses who are picky about their treats. — The lack of cinnamon smell and new texture could be disappointing and disliked by picky horses.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan varies

Factors: formula changes, storage conditions

Rating Distribution

3.3
9 reviews
5★
44%
4★
0%
3★
11%
2★
22%
1★
22%

Highlighted Reviews

— Lauren

"The cinnamon smell of these are amazing and they fit so well in the pockets of my breeches (they are small flat squares). Obviously, the horses love them too."

— Shari

"Totally changed the cookies, and for the worse. This new version has no cinnamon smell, our small square wafers, and do not have the crunch of the originals. The original cookies were round, very crisp and crunchy, and had a nice cinnamon smell. The middle of the bag was opened there was a very plea..."

Bottom Line

While some horses enjoy these treats, the recent formula change has led to widespread dissatisfaction. Potential buyers should consider the risk of their horses rejecting the new formula and the overall quality issues reported.

6.2 /10
Average