Kalmbach Feeds Milk Maker Goat Feed, 50-lb bag
In a Nutshell
- Increased milk production reported by some users
- Strong off-putting smell mentioned by multiple reviewers
- Inconsistent results in milk production
- Higher price point, but some find it worth it
- Contains benzoic acid, which is a concern for some buyers
Quick Verdict
While some users see increased milk production, the product has significant issues with smell and inconsistency in results. Owner reviews are mixed.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Increased Milk Production (4)
Some users report an increase in milk production.
-
Goats Love the Taste (3)
Reviewers note that goats enjoy the taste of the feed.
Cons
-
Strong Off-Putting Smell (4) major
Many users report a strong, unpleasant smell.
-
Variable Milk Production (2) major
Results in milk production are inconsistent among users.
-
Contains Benzoic Acid (1) minor
Concerns about the presence of benzoic acid in the ingredients.
-
High Price Point (2) minor
The product is considered more expensive compared to alternatives.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dairy goat owners — Those looking to increase milk production.
✗ Skip If
- • Those sensitive to strong smells — The product has a strong, off-putting smell.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Does this feed increase milk production in goats?
Some users report an increase in milk production, while others do not see any change or even a decrease.
What is the smell like?
The smell is described as strong and unpleasant, similar to soured milk or baby spit-up.
Does this feed contain any additives?
Yes, it contains benzoic acid, which some users find concerning.
Highlighted Reviews
"Milk production increases by 25-30% when I use Kalmbach milk maker versus my local store brand of milk goat pellets. My girls seem to like the taste. It's a little more expensive but worth every penny!"
"I am quite disappointed as the smell is very off putting and my goats are definitely not producing more milk. As a matter of fact they have decreased milk production on Kalmbach Milk Maker. I also noticed that there is benzoic acid in the ingredients. That was an oversight on my part, but I do not l..."
Bottom Line
Consider alternatives if smell is a concern. Otherwise make this a trial product to gauge the best use requirements vs. cost-benefit