Modesto Milling Organic Non-Soy 17% Protein Layer Crumbles Chicken Feed
In a Nutshell
- Mixed reviews due to powdery consistency and high cost
- Some success with hens and ducks, particularly in improving egg production
- Quality issues and inconsistent results reported by several users
- High price point and potential quality issues make it a consider but not highly recommended feed
Quick Verdict
The Modesto Milling Organic Non-Soy 17% Protein Layer Crumbles Chicken Feed has mixed reviews, with some users reporting powdery consistency and high cost. However, it has seen some success with certain pet types like ducks and hens. Overall, it may not be the best value for money but has shown positive results for specific users.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
The feed often arrives as mostly powder, which makes it difficult to use effectively.
Prevention: Consider contacting the supplier for a replacement if the product arrives in powdery form.
The feed has been reported to arrive past its freshness point, rendering it unusable.
Prevention: Check the expiration date before use and contact the supplier for a replacement if necessary.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Increased Egg Production (2)
Several users noted that switching to this feed improved egg production in their hens and ducks.
-
Non-GMO and Organic (3)
The feed is appreciated for being organic and non-GMO, which is a priority for some pet owners.
-
High Protein Content (1)
The 17% protein content is beneficial for the health of layer hens and ducks.
Cons
-
Powdery Consistency (3) major
The feed often arrives as mostly powder, making it difficult to use effectively.
-
High Price (3) major
The cost of the feed is considered too high for the quality and quantity provided.
-
Quality Issues (1) critical
There have been complaints about the feed not being fresh and arriving past its freshness point.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Pet owners looking for organic and non-GMO feed — The feed is appreciated for its organic and non-GMO ingredients, which are healthier for their pets.
- • Owners of layers and ducks — The feed has been reported to improve egg production in hens and ducks, making it a good choice for these pet types.
✗ Skip If
- • Budget-conscious buyers — The high cost of the feed and the powdery consistency make it not worth the investment, especially for those on a budget.
- • Owners expecting fresh and consistent feed — The feed has quality issues, including arriving past its freshness point, making it unreliable for consistent use.
Durability & Care
Factors: Storage conditions, Usage frequency, Maintenance practices
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Store in a cool, dry place to maintain freshness
- 💡 Use within the recommended timeframe for best results
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this feed suitable for hens and ducks?
Yes, it is suitable and has been reported to improve egg production in hens and ducks.
What are the common quality issues with this feed?
The feed often arrives as mostly powder, and there have been complaints about it being past its freshness point.
How does the cost compare to other feeds?
The feed is considered more expensive than other options, which may not justify the quality issues reported.
Highlighted Reviews
"Our ducks stopped laying on Purina Duck Food.... for months. It was mostly dust, few pellets, bag after bag, at multiple stores. FOUR days on this organic food resulted in eggs daily...and they really love it! Thanks Modesto Milling."
"I ordered this for the first time as I was looking for an organic layer crumble for my flock of 5 chickens. I received this with a mill date that rendered it over 4 months old -- i.e. well past freshness point and not heathy. I called up Chewy to complain, and they, lovely as always, sent a new re..."
Bottom Line
If you're looking for an organic, non-GMO feed for your layer hens or ducks, this product could be worth a try. However, be prepared for potential quality issues and a higher price point. It may not be the best value for money, so consider your needs and budget carefully.