American Journey Landmark Salmon Recipe Grain-Free Crunchy Biscuits Dog Treats, 10-oz bag
In a Nutshell
- Good value for larger dogs
- Strong fishy smell is a downside
- Durable but hard to break
- Some ingredient concerns
- Worth it if your dog loves the flavor
Quick Verdict
American Journey Landmark Salmon Recipe Grain-Free Crunchy Biscuits Dog Treats are generally well-liked by dogs, particularly larger breeds. However, the strong fishy smell is a significant drawback for many owners. The size of the treats is a bit too large for smaller dogs, and the durability of the biscuits is generally good. Owners appreciate the value for the price, but some find the smell and ingredients to be issues.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Bacteria (bugs) found in the treats
Prevention: Inspect treats carefully before giving to pets.
Strong fishy smell
Prevention: Consider alternative treats with milder smells.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
High Enjoyment (5)
Dogs love the salmon flavor
-
Good for Teeth (2)
Crunchy texture helps with dental health
-
Value for Money (3)
Affordable and satisfying for dogs
-
Perfect Size for Large Breeds (2)
Suitable for larger dogs
-
Versatile Use (2)
Can be used in various scenarios
Cons
-
Strong Fishy Smell (3) major
Overpowering smell is unpleasant
-
Hard to Break (2) minor
Treats are too hard to break into smaller pieces
-
Ingredients Concerns (1) major
Ingredients list includes controversial items
-
Size Issues for Smaller Dogs (1) major
Too large for smaller dogs
-
Quality Control Issues (1) critical
Prsence of bugs in the treats
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Owners of large breed dogs — Treats are large and suitable for bigger dogs.
- • Pet owners looking for grain-free treats — Product is specified as grain-free.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of smaller dogs — Treats are too large for smaller breeds.
- • Pet owners sensitive to strong smells — The treats have a very strong fishy smell.
Durability & Care
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are these treats suitable for small dogs?
No, the treats are too large for smaller dogs.
Do these treats have a strong smell?
Yes, many reviewers mention a strong fishy smell.
Can these treats be used for training?
Yes, many reviewers use them as training rewards.
Are these treats grain-free?
Yes, they are specified as grain-free.
Do the smell lingers
Yes, the smell can linger in your dog’s mouth for days
Highlighted Reviews
"My Mini Schauzer enjoys these biscuits so much. I usually save them for a reward after I brush or groom him. He knows if he's a really good boy he will get one or two when I finish so when we finish he runs to the place where I keep them, sits and waits for his treat."
"I bought six bags of these treats when they were on sale. I looked into the reviews and ingredients and they met all of my check points so I ordered in bulk. I wish I wouldn’t have! These make smell like fish and it is not faint at all, it is super over powering! And on top of that the smell linge..."
Bottom Line
In summary, if you have a large dog who enjoys a strong fishy flavor and you’re not bothered by the smell, these treats are a good choice. However, if you have a smaller dog or are sensitive to strong smells, you might want to explore other alternatives.