Smart Cookie Barkery Skin & Coat Salmon Dog Treats, 8-oz bag
In a Nutshell
- Effective for skin and coat health
- Too hard for some dogs, especially smaller breeds
- Well-received flavor but texture is a significant issue
- Not suitable as a treat for all dogs, may need to be used sparingly
Quick Verdict
These treats are praised for their skin benefits but criticized for being too hard and not appealing to all dogs.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Too hard for all dogs
Prevention: Use with caution or not at all for smaller breeds or dogs with weak jaws.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Skin and Coat Benefits (4)
Helps with improving skin and coat health in dogs.
-
Limited Ingredients (2)
Made with limited ingredients, good for dogs with sensitivities.
-
Effective for Alopecia (2)
Helped resolve alopecia in some dogs.
Cons
-
Too Hard (6) critical
Treats are very hard and difficult to chew.
-
Size Issues (2) major
Treats are too big for some dogs, resulting in breakage and smaller pieces.
-
Not Suitable for All Dogs (4) major
Some dogs will not eat these treats due to the hard texture.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dogs with sensitive skin — Treats are formulated for sensitive skin.
- • Dogs with alopecia — Helped resolve alopecia in some dogs.
✗ Skip If
- • Dogs with weak jaws or small breeds — Treats are too hard and large.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Use sparingly for pets with strong jaws.
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Do the treats tackle alopecia?
Yes. Helps with Alopecia
Highlighted Reviews
"My dog's been diagnosed with AlopeciaX -- meaning the vet isn't sure what's causing the hair loss -- and slowly but surely he was losing more and more of his luxurious coat. Then a girlfriend gifted me these treats for him. Not only does he love them (salivates at the sight of the bag) but his fur ..."
"I did see where it said it's a "crunchy" treat but I beg to differ with that. I did call chewy about it and they were extremely nice and said they would give me a refund but that's not why I called them. I was calling to see if they were supposed to be that hard of a treat and basically they said th..."
Bottom Line
These treats are a good option if your dog can tolerate the hard texture but may not be suitable for all dogs, especially smaller breeds. Consider these treats for their skin and coat benefits but be prepared for potential difficulties in feeds.