Cat Toys Editor's Choice

Mad Cat Big Burrito Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy

Item: Mad Cat Big Burrito Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy
Rating: 4.3
Author: Furdio

10 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 90% confidence

8.3 /10

Quality

7.5

Value

8.0

Design

8.5

Function

8.0

Durability

7.0

Buy on Chewy

In a Nutshell

Cats love the crinkling sound and catnip
Durability issues with the silver foil
Supervision recommended for safety

Quick Verdict

The Mad Cat Big Burrito Kicker Catnip & Silvervine Cat Toy is a hit with cats due to its design and functionality, but durability issues are noted.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 10

Would Recommend 80%

Would Buy Again 60%

Avg Lifespan 12-14 months

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs

Caution

🐈 Cats

Suitable

Critical Warnings

high

Silver foil can be punctured by claws and teeth, posing a risk of ingestion.

Prevention: Supervise playtime and replace the toy once punctures appear.

Pros & Cons

Pros

Cats Love It (7)
Cats are drawn to the crinkling sound and catnip.
Great Size (4)
The toy is large enough for cats to kick it with their back legs.
Durable (4)
The toy has a good design that appears sturdy.
Cats Found It Irresistible (4)
Cats are taken by the craving to bite and kick the burrito.
Versatile Usage (6)
Cats use it for various activities like fetching, cuddling, and biting.

Cons

Durability Issues (3) major
The silver foil is easily punctured by claws and teeth.
Crinkle Sound Detrimental (1) major
Many cats dislike the crinkling sound which affects their engagement.

Tip: Removing the crinkle aspect might make the toy more appealing to some cats.
Co-Cat Ignored This Toy (1) minor
One reviewer's cats rejected this toy while liking others.

Who Is This For?

✓ Best For

• Cat owners with active pets — The toy's design and materials are appealing to cats, especially those who like to kick and cuddle.
• First-time cat toy buyers — The toy is highly regarded for its appeal to cats and durability concerns can be managed with supervision.

✗ Skip If

• Those looking for a durable, long-lasting toy. — Multiple reviews mentioned durability issues, making it not suitable for extended play without supervision.
• Owners of cats who dislike crinkling sounds — Several reviews indicate that the crinkling sound deters some cats from engaging with the toy.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan A few weeks to 2+ years

Factors: Heavy chewing, unsupervised play

Cleaning Methods

✗ Machine wash

✗ Hand wash

✗ Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

💡 Supervise playtime
💡 Check for punctures regularly

Floor Compatibility

✓ Hardwood

✓ Tile

✓ Carpet

✓ Vinyl

✓ Laminate

Rating Distribution

4.3

10 reviews

5★

70%

4★

3★

10%

2★

1★

20%

cuddling (2) crinkles (3) personality (4) broken (3) creased (1) horn shape (5)

Common Questions

Is this toy durable?

The toy has mixed reviews on durability. Some users report it lasting 4 years, while others mention punctures after a few minutes of play.

Do cats like the crinkling sound?

Some cats enjoy the crinkling sound, but others dislike it. If your cat is sensitive to sounds, this toy might not be a good fit.

Is this toy safe for unsupervised play?

No, the toy is not safe for unsupervised play due to the risk of punctures and ingestion of the silver foil.

Highlighted Reviews

— Natalie

"All four of my cats love this burrito and stop to play with it every time they come into the living room. I like that it's big enough for them to kick-kick-kick with their back feet while biting and drooling all over the top of it. Just bought this one as a replacement after 4 years of use! My kitti..."

— Jennifer

"They both enjoy the dynamite kicker toy & the other silvervine toy, but neither of them will touch this toy"

Bottom Line

If you're looking for a toy that will entertain your cat, this is a great choice, but be prepared to replace it frequently or supervise playtime carefully.

8.3 /10

— Excellent