Kaytee Second Cut Timothy Hay Small Animal Food
In a Nutshell
- Discoloration and odor issues reported, indicating potential quality concerns.
- Mixed sentiment, with many negative reviews focusing on quality.
- Alternative products may be worth considering.
Quick Verdict
Kaytee Second Cut Timothy Hay has mixed reviews. Quality concerns and high negative sentiment reported.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Discoloration and degradation leading to nutritional loss.
Prevention: Check quality and freshness upon receipt.
Rotted and dusty hay, causing health concerns and smell problems.
Prevention: Consider changing brands or buying in smaller quantities to check.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
High Nutrition (1)
Some reviewers note higher nutritional value compared to other hays.
-
Soft and Green (1)
Some reviews praise the texture and appearance of the hay.
Cons
-
Discoloration and Smell (4) major
Many reviews mention the hay being yellow and brownish, which indicates a loss of nutrients.
-
Lack of Freshness (2) major
The hay’s freshness is a common concern, with many users reporting rotten and dusty hay.
-
Quality Issues (5) critical
Consistently reported issues with quality, including discoloration and rotten parts.
Quality Trend: Declining
Recent reviews report significant quality issues.
Mixed, with some positive and negative sentiments.
More negative, focusing on quality and freshness.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Small animal owners who value high-nutrition hay — Some users praise the nutritional value of this hay compared to other brands.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners concerned about quality and freshness — Multiple quality issues have been reported, making it an unreliable choice for some customers.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is the Kaytee Second Cut Timothy Hay suitable for guinea pigs?
Yes, it is suitable for guinea pigs, but quality issues have been reported.
Does the hay come in different sizes?
No specific mentions of size variations.
Highlighted Reviews
"This second cut Timothy hay seems to be of great quality! My rabbits love it & I’m very happy that it has higher nutrition than other hays. Thanks & God bless!"
"The rabbit was not happy with the hay. I will be going back to the other Timothy hay that I get at a local store."
Bottom Line
Given the mixed reviews and quality concerns, consider alternatives or smaller quantities to test before full commitment.