BARK Shifty Sid the Squid Plush Dog Toy, Multi Colored
In a Nutshell
- Cute design but significant durability issues.
- Many users report choking hazards due to unraveling strings.
- Some dogs love the sensory features, like the squeaker and tentacles.
Quick Verdict
The BARK Shifty Sid the Squid Plush Dog Toy has a mixed reception. While some dogs love it, many reviews point out significant durability issues and safety concerns due to unraveling strings that can pose choking hazards. Overall, it's a cute design but comes with notable risks.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Choking hazard from unraveling strings
Prevention: Do not leave the toy with the dog unattended, and replace it immediately if any signs of wear are noticed.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Engaging design (5)
The toy's design, with fluttering tentacles and a squeaker, is very attractive to dogs, especially those that enjoy interactive play.
-
Bright Colors (4)
The bright, multi-colored design of the toy is appealing and visually stimulating for both dogs and owners.
Cons
-
Durability Issues (13) critical
The toy's durability is a major concern due to the unraveling yarn on the legs and tentacles, which can cause a choking hazard.
-
Safety Concerns (10) critical
The unraveling strings from the toy can easily come off and pose a serious choking hazard for dogs, especially when they pull on it.
Quality Trend: Declining
Users at different times reported similar issues with durability and safety, with no improvements noted.
negative
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog owners with gentle chewers — The toy may last longer with non-aggressive dogs.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of aggressive chewers or large dogs — High risk of the toy unraveling and posing a choking hazard.
Durability & Care
Factors: Size of the dog, Aggressiveness of chewing, Supervision during playtime
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Supervise playtime
- 💡 Replace the toy frequently
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this toy safe for aggressive chewers?
No, the toy is not safe for aggressive chewers due to the risk of unraveling strings posing a choking hazard.
How long does this toy typically last?
The toy typically lasts from less than a day to a few days, depending on the dog's chewing habits.
Is this toy suitable for larger dogs?
No, it is not suitable for larger or aggressive dogs due to the risk of the toy falling apart and posing a choking hazard.
Are the strings safe to leave with a dog unsupervised?
It is not safe to leave the dog unsupervised with this toy due to the risk of unraveling strings posing a choking hazard.
Highlighted Reviews
"Our dog loves plush toys w/squeakers & crunchy sounds. Especially loves the flailing squid arms! It is a very well made plush and can hold up to rough play. I am not sure how a smaller dog than her would do with this (she is 18 lbs and 15 in. high at shoulders), unless they think they're a big dog l..."
"I love BARK brand toys and have been purchasing them for years but the quality on this one is awful. All the little spots on the the legs are actually thick yearn that very easily unravels. My dog isnt much of a chewer but I unfortunately had to throw this out on day 1 because it became a chocking h..."
Bottom Line
While the toy is aesthetically pleasing and some dogs love it, the severe durability and safety issues make it a risky purchase. Consider this only if you're prepared to closely monitor playtime and potentially lose the toy quickly. Safer alternatives may be a better choice.