Brandon McMillan Shake & Break Dog Training Tool
In a Nutshell
- Effective for getting a dog's attention.
- Criticized for negative reinforcement methods.
- Size and noise level are concerns.
- Positive reinforcement methods are suggested as alternatives.
Quick Verdict
The Brandon McMillan Shake & Break Dog Training Tool has divided opinions. While some find it effective for training, others raise concerns about its negative reinforcement methods and practicality.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Potential to cause fear and anxiety in dogs due to negative reinforcement.
Prevention: Consider positive reinforcement methods instead.
Size and weight make it impractical for small dogs or for use on walks.
Prevention: Evaluate the tool's size and weight before purchasing.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Attention Grabber (3)
Effective in getting a dog's attention, especially for stubborn or distracted dogs.
-
Easy to Use (2)
Simple to operate and understand, does not require complex setup.
Cons
-
Fear-Based Training (7) critical
Users are concerned about the negative reinforcement method that can cause fear and anxiety in dogs.
-
Size and Weight (3) major
The tool is deemed too large and cumbersome for practical use, especially on walks or with smaller dogs.
-
Outdated and Ineffective (3) major
Some users find the tool ineffective and outdated, suggesting it's more of a gimmick.
-
No Instructions (2) minor
The tool lacks clear instructions, leaving users confused about proper usage.
-
Not Loud Enough (2) minor
For some users, the tool is not loud enough to be effective with larger or deafer dogs.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog owners looking for an attention-getter — Effective in gaining a dog's attention, especially for distracted or stubborn dogs.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of small dogs or those preferring positive reinforcement — Size and negative reinforcement concerns.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this tool suitable for small dogs?
No, due to its size and weight, it is better suited for medium to large dogs.
Does the tool come with instructions?
No, users report that there are no instructions provided with the tool.
What are the potential risks of using this tool?
The tool may cause fear and anxiety in dogs due to negative reinforcement methods.
Highlighted Reviews
"Great product! My dogs have become deaf to my voice and ignore my commands, each dog has been through four 6 week dog training classes. One dog is exceptionally stubborn, and this shaker really caught his attention. He would not listen to command, so I shook this an he immediately stopped the behavi..."
"This is not a positive reinforcement training tool to use on your dog. This trains by making your dog scared and is a NEGATIVE reinforcement device. This type of training can cause unintended consequences such as anxiety and even aggression in your dog. Please don't use this and get a clicker and so..."
Bottom Line
This product is not universally recommended due to concerns about negative reinforcement and practical issues. Potential users should consider positive reinforcement alternatives.