American Journey Salmon & Sweet Potato Recipe Limited Ingredient Dog Treats
In a Nutshell
- Dogs love the flavor and size of these treats.
- Consistent issues with crumbling and broken pieces.
- Overall good for special occasions or as a topper.
Quick Verdict
These treats are generally loved by dogs for their taste and size, but buyers should be aware of the frequent complaints about crumbling and inconsistent size.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Crumbling and breaking frequently.
Prevention: Reject the order when received.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Dog Appeal (2)
Dogs are highly enthusiastic about the flavor and texture of the treats.
-
Healthy Ingredients (3)
Salmon as the primary ingredient and high-quality ingredients are appealing to buyers.
-
Size Variability (2)
The size of the treats is ideal for various training sessions and occasional rewards.
Cons
-
Crumbling Issues (4) major
Many treats arrive crumbled or broken, making them unusable for larger dogs or as intended treats.
-
Hard to Chew (2) minor
The treats are sometimes too hard, especially for smaller dogs, leading users to break them apart.
Tip: Breaking the hard treats into smaller bits
-
Packaging Issues (3)
The treats often arrive smashed, small or are broken due to poor packaging and transit issues.
Quality Trend: Declining
Recent reviews mention more crumbling and inconsistent sizing issues
neutral
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog owners looking for high-value, health-focused treats — The treats are considered healthy with high nutritional values that dogs can enjoy.
- • Dog owners needing larger treat sizes for training — The size of the treats is large enough to be used as treats.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of large dogs who need durable, large treats. — The product's consistency in size might compromise on durability.
- • Owners wanting consistently shaped and sized treats for training — The change in size compromises consistency.
- • Owners looking for soft and chewy treats — Most of the time the product comes in as average-sized and effective chewing product for dogs
Durability & Care
Factors: Packaging, Shipping
Cleaning Methods
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are these treats suitable for smaller dogs?
Yes, but you may need to break them into smaller pieces.
Do these treats crumble easily?
Yes, many users report receiving the treats crumbled or broken.
Highlighted Reviews
"My dog LOVES these treats! She'll stand by the treat box until I give her one. Then she dances and prances! "
"Just received the bag of these treats and they were smashed into little pieces...too small to even give to my dogs! You would think with all the orders Chewy deals with they would at least wrap/protect products like this. Will buy other treats at a store now where I can see what the biscuits look ..."
Bottom Line
If your dog loves these treats and you can overlook the occasional crumbly ones, they are a good choice. But if consistent quality is important, look at other brands.