Dog Treats Decrease in Product Quality Trending Down
Chewy Natural Peanut Butter Flavor Dental Chew Dog Treats (FORMERLY TRUE ACRE FOODS)

Chewy Natural Peanut Butter Flavor Dental Chew Dog Treats (FORMERLY TRUE ACRE FOODS)

By Chewy 11 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 85% confidence
6.2 /10
Quality
6.0
Value
6.5
Design
6.0
Function
6.5
Durability
7.0

In a Nutshell

  • Dogs have enjoyed the treats for dental health
  • New formulation harder and less enjoyed by many customers and pets
  • Significant sentimennt change due to new formulation

Quick Verdict

Many customers express disappointment with the new formulation, calling it harder and less palatable. Some report their dogs no longer enjoy the treats.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 11
Would Recommend 36%
Would Buy Again 36%
Avg Lifespan 2-3 Months

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Suitable
🐈 Cats
Caution

Critical Warnings

high

Dogs having trouble chewing on the new formulation

Prevention: Avoid using with dogs prone to dental issues

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Dental Benefits (3)

    Effective in maintaining dental health as reported by multiple users

  • Natural Ingredients (2)

    Made from natural ingredients

  • Dog Enjoyment (2)

    Dogs enjoy the peanut butter flavor

Cons

  • Hard to Break (4) major

    New formulation is too hard to break, making it inconvenient for smaller dogs or multiple treat usage.

    Tip: Users suggested looking for alternate treats or breaking the treats earlier in smaller pieces.

  • Dog Disinterest (3) minor

    Dogs are less interested in the new, harder treats

  • Severe Hardness (3) high

    Dogs having trouble chewing on the new formulation

  • Changes in Quality (4) high

    Notion of Quality and consistency changing

Quality Trend: Declining

Customers report significant changes in the product's texture and hardness, leading to decreased satisfaction. The new formulation is perceived as inferior to the previous version, which had a softer, more palatable texture.

Older Reviews Said:

positive

Newer Reviews Say:

negative

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Dog owners seeking dental health benefits — These treats are praised for their effectiveness in maintaining dental health in dogs.
  • Pets who enjoy peanut butter — The peanut butter flavor is a hit with many dogs, making it an enjoyable treat.
  • Owners looking for longer-lasting treats — The treats are noted for their durability, keeping dogs engaged for extended periods.

Skip If

  • Owners of smaller dogs — The new formulation is too hard, making it difficult for smaller dogs to chew.
  • Owners seeking softer, more pliable treats — The current formulation may not be suitable for those who prefer softer, more easily chewed treats.
  • Owners of dogs with dental issues — The hardness of the new treats may exacerbate dental issues in some dogs.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan Multiple weeks to months

Factors: Hard core freezing, Long chew durations, Negative altering in the product configuration

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • 💡 Store in a cool, dry place
  • 💡 Use for larger breeds due to hardness
  • 💡 Breaking down the product for children

Rating Distribution

2.7
11 reviews
5★
36%
4★
0%
3★
0%
2★
36%
1★
27%
dental benefits (4) natural ingredients (2) hardness (7) formulation change (4) dog disinterest (3)

Common Questions

What is included in this product?

The product includes dental chews for dogs with a peanut butter flavor, designed to maintain dental health.

Highlighted Reviews

— Bobette 1 found helpful

"Just before bedtime, we walk around the pool, check out the moon, look for critters and generally secure the perimeters. Then, my pups exuberantly get their beloved "toothbrush bones." This is the biggest treat for them! My girl holds hers between her paws (like a toothbrush, or a carrot). It took a..."

— Pamela

"My dogs have loved these dental treats for many years. Every day each dog got half a stick. They offered a good, solid chew and all of my dogs liked the peanut butter flavor. The new ones are so hard that (1) I can't just break one in half and (2) the dogs leave them in their crates, whereas before ..."

Bottom Line

If you are considering these dental chews for your dog, be prepared for a change in formula that may not be well-received by your pet. Those who appreciate the dental benefits and natural ingredients may still find them satisfactory, but small or finicky dogs might struggle with the new toughness. If your dog is used to the softer texture from prior formulations, consider an alternative until Chewy addresses the quality discrepancies.

6.2 /10
Below Average