The Lazy Dog Cookie Co. Muttster Mash Pup-PIE Dog Treat
In a Nutshell
- Dogs love the taste and smell.
- Easy to break apart for smaller pieces.
- Adorable pie-shaped design.
- Can be too hard for smaller dogs or puppies.
Quick Verdict
The Lazy Dog Cookie Co. Muttster Mash Pup-PIE is a hit with dogs and owners alike. It's easy to break apart, has a great smell, and is reasonably priced. The main downside is that it can be too hard for smaller dogs or puppies.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Great Taste (9)
Dogs love the flavor, often running back for more.
-
Nice Design (6)
Adorable and fun pie shape, great for special occasions.
-
Easy to Break (4)
Convenient for portion control and multiple dogs.
-
Fair Price (3)
Reasonably priced for the quality and size.
-
Soft Texture (for some) (3)
Soft enough for some dogs to enjoy easily.
Cons
-
Too Hard for Small Dogs (3) major
Can be difficult for smaller dogs or puppies to chew.
-
Texture Preference (2) minor
Some dogs prefer softer treats.
Tip: Consider breaking into smaller pieces or soaking in water.
-
Occasional Softness Issues (1) minor
Some reviews mentioned the treat being too hard.
Tip: Soaking in water can help.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog owners with medium to large breeds — The treat is soft and easy to chew for medium to large breeds.
- • Owners looking for special occasion treats — The pie-shaped design is perfect for birthdays and holidays.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners with small dogs or puppies — The treat can be too hard for smaller dogs or puppies to chew.
Durability & Care
Factors: Storage conditions, Dog's chewing habits
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Store in a cool, dry place to maintain freshness.
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this treat suitable for small dogs?
No, it can be too hard for smaller dogs or puppies to chew.
How should I store this treat?
Store in a cool, dry place to maintain freshness.
Can I use this treat for training?
Yes, it can be broken into smaller pieces for training rewards.
Is this treat good for special occasions?
Yes, the pie-shaped design makes it perfect for birthdays and holidays.
Can this treat be used for multiple dogs?
Yes, it can be broken into smaller pieces to share among multiple dogs.
Highlighted Reviews
"My dogs love these cakes so much. I got one for her birthday by the same brand and after how much she loved it I was delighted to see a Halloween version! She has finished one so I bought two backups and one each for gifts for other family member's dogs. This cake smells good enough to eat myself. C..."
"I bought this to split between my dogs and my sister’s new puppy as a Halloween themed treat. My dogs are 14 and 3 and will eat anything. My sister’s puppy was about 9 months at the time and in full blown teething mode. Unfortunately, while he teeths, he only wants soft things and my sister had ..."
Bottom Line
If you're looking for a fun and delicious treat for your dog, the Muttster Mash Pup-PIE is an excellent choice. Just be aware that it may be too hard for smaller dogs or puppies.?