Pet Treats Consistent quality concerns from packaging issues and tough skin.
Only Natural Pet Wild Caught Salmon Grain-Free Freeze-Dried Cat Treats

Only Natural Pet Wild Caught Salmon Grain-Free Freeze-Dried Cat Treats

By Only Natural Pet 21 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 90% confidence
8.3 /10
Quality
7.5
Value
7.8
Design
7.0
Function
8.5
Durability
7.0

In a Nutshell

  • Healthy with natural ingredients
  • Strong odor and tough skin issues
  • Many cats love them, but some have strong concerns about size and packaging problems.

Quick Verdict

These salmon treats are generally well-received for their health benefits, but the strong odor and tough skin are frequent complaints among both cats and owners. Some reviewers mention that the treats are too big or that the packaging is not always optimal. Overall, a good choice for cat owners looking for healthy options, but be prepared to pre-pack or size down the treats.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 21
Would Recommend 62%
Would Buy Again 67%
Avg Lifespan null

Pet Compatibility

🐕 Dogs
Caution
🐈 Cats
Suitable

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Natural Ingredients (8)

    The treats are made with wild-caught salmon and are grain-free, touted by reviewers as a healthier option.

  • Health Benefits (7)

    Many reviewers highlight the health benefits and natural ingredients as positives.

  • Cat Enjoyment (5)

    Cats generally enjoy the taste and go crazy for them.

Cons

  • Strong Odor (4) major

    The strong odor is a common complaint, both for cats and owners.

  • Hard Skin (5) major

    Many reviews mention the hard, thick skin on the treats as an issue.

    Tip: Owner usually have to remove the skin.

  • Pulverized Packaging (3) minor

    Occasionally, the treats arrive broken or damaged within the packaging.

Who Is This For?

Best For

  • Health-conscious cat owners — Looking for natural, grain-free treats for their cats.

Skip If

  • Squeamish owners or cats that dislike strong fishy smells — The strong odor might be off-putting.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan null

Factors: storage, packaging

Cleaning Methods

Machine wash
Hand wash
Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • 💡 Store in cool dry place to keep freshness.

Floor Compatibility

Hardwood
Tile
Carpet
Vinyl
Laminate

Rating Distribution

4.5
21 reviews
5★
38%
4★
14%
3★
5%
2★
10%
1★
5%
Natural Ingredients (6) Healthy (5) Strong Odor (4) Tough Skin (5)

Common Questions

Do cats like the flavor of these treats?

Yes, the majority stand 3.8/21 will recommend the cat flavor.

Can smaller cats eat this treat?

Size may matter for some cats. Some cats may not like the size have issues during first try has no indication.

How does it compare to grain-based treats?

Cats typically prefer natural, grain-free treats over grain-based ones, especially if they have sensitivities to grains.

Highlighted Reviews

— Judy

"Cat loves the small treats, after I’ve done my best to remove the iron-like skin on most of the treats, and then make them smaller. Do like the concept and Only Natural products in general, but not sure will re-schemafied again."

— Angpi

"the skin fish that is on it is super hard to eat it. my cat refuses to take it"

Bottom Line

If you're looking for a healthy treat with natural ingredients, these are a solid option. Just be prepared to deal with the strong odor and potential skin issues. Many reviews suggest they are better broken into smaller pieces before giving them to your cat, making them tasty morsels.

8.3 /10
Excellent