Top Dog Chews Natural Water Buffalo Bully Horns Dog Treats
In a Nutshell
- High variability in quality and durability
- Some dogs love the treats, others have severe safety issues
- Manufacturer claims contradict many users' experiences
Quick Verdict
Top Dog Chews Natural Water Buffalo Bully Horns have been praised by some owners for their natural scent and durability, but many reviews highlight severe issues with splintering and the smell. They seem to be a hit or miss depending on the batch quality.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Swallowing large chunks
Prevention: Monitor chewing, remove if large pieces break off
Splintering
Prevention: Supervise and stop usage if splintering occurs
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Natural Teeth Cleaning (2)
Many reviewers mentioned these chews help clean their dogs' teeth.
-
Long Lying Horns (1)
Reviews mention that these bulk horns last longer
-
Large Size (1)
Larger chews are better suited for larger, heavier chewers
Cons
-
Splintering Issues (5) major
Many dogs suffer from the splintering problem while chewing and risky as the piece come stark and sharp
-
Unpleasant Smell (3) major
The natural scent is too strong and unpleasant for many users.
-
Thin Base (2) critical
Many complaints about the thin base leading to pieces breaking off
-
Break/Ease of break? (2) major
User deal with dented and irregular shaped
Quality Trend: Declining
Increasing reports of splintering and reduced durability in recent reviews
mixed
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog owners looking for natural, long-lasting chews — Provides durable chewing experience and perceived dental benefits for taste
✗ Skip If
- • Owners with aggressive chewers or concerns about durability and safety — High risk of splintering and swallowing large pieces, which is a gifititharding chewers and incompatible
Durability & Care
Factors: dog size, chewing intensity, manufacturing quality
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Supervise chewing
- 💡 Remove if piece breaks off
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are these chews safe for aggressive chewers?
No, many reviews mention splintering and the base breaking off, which can be dangerous for aggressive chewers.
How long do these chews last?
Duration varies, but many users report them lasting 1-3 months depending on the dog's chewing habits.
Do these chews have a strong smell?
Yes, many reviews mention a strong, unpleasant natural scent. Overpowering smell
Highlighted Reviews
"Good deal. My 4 pups love these. They last long."
"Both dogs immediately began chewing on this base and breaking off pieces and swallowing them. Complete waste of money. Horns that I purchased from pet stores locally have very thick bases that the dogs are incapable of breaking off pieces."
Bottom Line
Be cautious when buying, may not be a good fit for aggressive chewers, and careful observation is necessary while the dog enjoys the chew.