Redbarn 7" Bully Flat Weave Dog Treat
In a Nutshell
- Strong, unpleasant odor reported by some users
- Long-lasting and durable, but with some durability issues
- Good value for money if the odor is not an issue
Quick Verdict
The Redbarn 7" Bully Flat Weave Dog Treat is a durable, long-lasting treat for dogs, but some users reported a strong, unpleasant odor. While it offers good value for money, the smell may be a deal-breaker for some pet owners. Most users were happy with the durability, but a few reported issues with the product not holding up as expected. Overall, it's a mixed bag with some minor issues but could be worth a try for those looking for a long-lasting treat.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Strong, unpleasant odor that can deter use
Prevention: Consider purchasing with caution if you or your family have sensitivity
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Durable and Long-Lasting (4)
Holds up well to aggressive chewers, lasting a long time.
-
Good Value for Money (3)
Offers good value, especially for longer-lasting chews.
-
Suitable for Aggressive Chewers (3)
Holds up to strong chewers, which is a significant plus for many pet owners.
Cons
-
Strong Unpleasant Odor (3) high
Many users reported a strong, unpleasant smell that was off-putting.
-
Lack of Packaging and Hygiene Concerns (1) medium
Items were not wrapped and exposed, raising concerns about hygiene, especially during the pandemic.
Quality Trend: Declining
Recent reviews indicate a decline in quality perception, with issues of strong odors and durability concerns.
generally positive
mixed to negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Pet owners with aggressive chewers — The durability and longevity make it an excellent treat for stronger chewers
✗ Skip If
- • Pet owners sensitive to strong odors — The strong, unpleasant smell was a major drawback for many users.
Durability & Care
Factors: pet size and chewing habit
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Does this product smell strong?
Yes, many reviewers mentioned a strong, unpleasant odor.
Is this treat durable?
For many users, yes, but some experienced issues with quick deterioration.
Is this product worth the price?
Yes, for those who can tolerate the smell, it offers good value for money.
Highlighted Reviews
"Fred loves them. Usually, the bully sticks don’t last long around him, but the twists last well over a week."
"The stench that emanated from this bone was so bad I threw it away. I ordered two so checked the other and it smelled as bad without even being chewed on. I’ve had good luck with Red Barn bullies even though they have an odor so I think they must have been rancid. It was unfortunate for my dogs as..."
Bottom Line
If you're looking for a durable, long-lasting treat for your dog and don't mind a strong odor, this could be a good option. However, if the smell is a concern, you might want to consider alternatives. Always check the latest reviews before purchasing, as quality and smell can vary between batches.