Pet Treats
Charmy Rainbow Trout Fillet Air-Dried Dog & Cat Treats, 2.60-oz bag

Charmy Rainbow Trout Fillet Air-Dried Dog & Cat Treats, 2.60-oz bag

By Charmy 4 reviews analyzed Updated Oct 2023 80% confidence
4.8 /10
Quality
5.0
Value
5.0
Design
4.0
Function
5.0
Durability
4.5

In a Nutshell

  • Pets love the taste and health benefits.
  • Strong smell is a consistent but polarizing feature.
  • Good value for money given the positive impact on pets.
  • Great for dogs and cats, with some adjustments needed for cats.

Quick Verdict

These treats are a hit with pets, offering health benefits and strong flavor, but the intense smell might be a turn-off for some owners. The cost is justified by the quality and pet enthusiasm.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 4
Would Recommend 100%
Would Buy Again 75%
Avg Lifespan not specified

Pet Compatibility

πŸ• Dogs
Suitable
🐈 Cats
Suitable

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Tasty and Enjoyable (4)

    Pets are highly enthusiastic about the taste of these treats, which is a repeat mention in reviews.

  • Good Value (2)

    Reviewers agree that the health benefits and pet approval make the cost worthwhile despite the strong smell.

  • Health Benefits (2)

    Pets' skin, coat, and joint health seem to benefit from these fish-based treats, making them a healthy option.

  • Bonding Experience (1)

    These treats can be an excellent bonding experience between owners and pets due to their appeal and nutritional benefits.

Cons

  • Strong Smell (4) major

    While pets enjoy the smell, some owners find it too intense and off-putting.

    Tip: Only keep these treats in an airtight container after opening and avoid opening the container where the smell might linger.

Who Is This For?

βœ“ Best For

  • β€’ Pet owners looking for high-quality, healthy treats β€” These treats offer good health benefits and are well-liked by pets, particularly for improving skin/coat health.
  • β€’ Owners of multiple dogs or cats β€” The treats are well-received across various pets and can be used as a daily treat and topper, making them versatile for multiple pet households.

βœ— Skip If

  • β€’ Owners sensitive to strong smells β€” The potent aroma may be unbearable for some human owners, which could outweigh the benefits of the treats for pets.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan not specified

Rating Distribution

4.8
4 reviews
5β˜…
75%
4β˜…
25%
3β˜…
0%
2β˜…
0%
1β˜…
0%
tasty (5) enjoyable (4) effective (2) nutrition (4) smell (4)

Common Questions

Do these treats have a strong smell?

Yes, the reviews consistently mention a very strong fish smell, which may be a bit off-putting to some owners even though it doesn’t seem to bother the pets.

Are these treats suitable for both dogs and cats?

Yes. Dogs appear to love the treats in their entirety, while cats may benefit from smaller pieces cut from the treats.

Are they worth the cost?

Most reviewers who mentioned the cost believe it is well worth the nutritional value the treats deliver.

What health benefits do they offer?

The fish content in these treats is often highlighted as beneficial for pets’ skin, coat, and overall health.

Highlighted Reviews

β€” Sandra

"All six of my dogs absolutely love this. It is especially good for them and well worth the cost."

β€” Cindy

"The smell is too strong which I’m not sure if that’s normal. But nonetheless, they seemed to enjoy it. Always great to add fish into their diets."

Bottom Line

These treats are highly recommended for pet owners looking to boost their pets' health with a tasty, high-quality option. Be prepared for the strong smell, which can be both a pro and a con.

4.8 /10
β€” Excellent