Pure & Simple Pet 10" Rawhide Retriever Roll Dog Treat, X-Large
In a Nutshell
- Treats too small
- Cost too high for product.
- Smelled bad
Quick Verdict
Although acceptable by some pets, it is small for the huge cost.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Treats pose choking hazard due to small size and quick consumption.
Prevention: Ensure proper chewing under dog oversight
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Desirable Appearance (2)
Pets liked the appearance
Cons
-
Size Issues (6) major
The treat is smaller than advertised.
-
Durability (3) major
Treats do not last very long.
-
Smell (2) major
Treats smell bad.
-
Value for money (3) major
Treat appears to be overpriced.
Quality Trend: Declining
Older reviews do not point to the size as being a problem, but newer reviews definitely suggest the size is listed assuming a dog way too small.
positive to neutral
NEGATIVE
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Pet owners — The treat is appealing in appearance for pets.
✗ Skip If
- • Pet owners with small dogs — Ask if customer wants to buy something that looks like it is for a 10lbs dog.
Durability & Care
Factors: weight of the dog
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is the size correct for a labrador?
No
About how long should the treat last?
Surely it should last longer than it does given the cost - but the lowest estimate was 30 minutes and reaching closer to an hour seemed hard to do.
What does it smell like
Mostly bleach or nothing.
Highlighted Reviews
"My large dog loved it but it didn’t last every long."
"these might be X- large if you have a 10 pound dog. My Lab could eat all of these at once!!"
Bottom Line
Consider a different treat for your pet.