Acme 575 Shepherds Mouth Nickel Plated Brass Dog Whistle
In a Nutshell
- difficult to use
- steep learning curve
- mixed responses from dogs
- poor durability
- metallic taste concerns
Quick Verdict
This dog whistle offers a range of tones but requires significant practice to master. Many users found it difficult to produce the correct sound and reported that their dogs did not respond to it. Some users also noted a metallic taste and short lifespan. It may be a good option for experienced whistle users but not for beginners.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Range of tones (2)
Some users appreciate the variety of tones the whistle can produce.
Cons
-
Steep learning curve (5) major
Many users found it extremely difficult to produce the correct sound.
-
Dog unresponsiveness (4) major
Users reported that their dogs did not react to the sound.
-
Metallic taste (1) minor
Some users described an unpleasant metallic taste.
-
Short lifespan (2) minor
Some users reported the whistle breaking or malfunctioning quickly.
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Experienced dog trainers — May find the range of tones useful despite the learning curve.
✗ Skip If
- • Beginners — The steep learning curve and dog unresponsiveness make it unsuitable.
Durability & Care
Factors: frequency of use, storage conditions
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Good for beginners or experts?
There is steep learning curve and it seems difficult to use for beginners. Experts or anyone who is familiar with how to use the whistle might find it useful.
Highlighted Reviews
"This is a great product with a wide range of tones that you can make"
"Please don’t buy this crap.The whistle makes almost no sound, and it wasn’t worth my time and money to even try and “ train” my dogs with this."
Bottom Line
If you're an experienced dog trainer looking for a new whistle, you might find this one worth trying. However, beginners or those looking for a user-friendly and effective training tool should consider other options.