Pet Treats quality concerns
American Journey with Peanut Butter Grain-Free Oven Baked Crunchy Biscuit Dog Treats

American Journey with Peanut Butter Grain-Free Oven Baked Crunchy Biscuit Dog Treats

By American Journey 10 reviews analyzed Updated Nov 2025 85% confidence
7.5 /10
Quality
7.0
Value
8.0
Design
6.5
Function
8.5
Durability
7.5

In a Nutshell

  • Loved by many dogs, especially those who enjoy peanut butter
  • Hardness can be a drawback for some older or smaller breeds
  • Good value for money, according to reviews

Quick Verdict

These grain-free crunchy biscuits are a hit with dogs, especially for their peanut butter flavor. However, older dogs or those with dental issues may struggle with the hardness of these treats.

Quick Stats

Reviews Analyzed 10
Would Recommend 70%
Would Buy Again 70%
Avg Lifespan 1 - 3 months

Pet Compatibility

πŸ• Dogs
Suitable
🐈 Cats
Caution

Pros & Cons

Pros

  • Great Taste (5)

    Many dogs love the peanut butter flavor and texture.

  • Value for Money ()

    Reviewers find the treats to be a good buy.

Cons

  • Hardness (3) medium

    Some dogs, especially older ones, find the treats too hard to eat.

  • Bad Smell (1) minor

    Some reviewers mentioned a bad smell from the treats, indicating potential quality issues.

Quality Trend: Declining

Some reviews mentioned a change in smell, indicating a decline in quality in recent batches.

Older Reviews Said:

positive

Newer Reviews Say:

negative

Who Is This For?

βœ“ Best For

  • β€’ Dogs that enjoy hard, crunchy treats β€” They will love the peanut butter flavor and texture.
  • β€’ Owners looking for a good value β€” The treats are reasonably priced and reviewed as a good buy.

βœ— Skip If

  • β€’ Older dogs or dogs with dental issues β€” They may struggle with the hardness of the treats.

Durability & Care

Expected Lifespan a few weeks to a few months

Factors: Storage conditions, Feeding frequency

Cleaning Methods

βœ— Machine wash
βœ— Hand wash
βœ— Spot clean

Care Tips from Users

  • πŸ’‘ Store in a cool dry place
  • πŸ’‘ Use a sterilized bucket to give it to your dog

Rating Distribution

4.5
10 reviews
5β˜…
70%
4β˜…
0%
3β˜…
20%
2β˜…
0%
1β˜…
10%
taste (5) value (3) hardness (3) smell (1)

Common Questions

Are these treats suitable for older dogs?

Some older dogs may struggle with the hardness, but many enjoy the flavor and texture. Consider softer treats if your dog has dental issues.

How long do these treats last?

These treats can last a few weeks to a few months if stored properly.

Highlighted Reviews

β€” Angela

"Neighbor’s dog treks over to see me every day to receive these treats. She must truly love them as she’s old, hips are shot, and painful for her to walk. But make it over here to see me and get these treats she does."

β€” Deborah

"These treats used to smell like you opened a jar of peanut butter. This last batch of bags I purchased smell like rancid oil."

Bottom Line

If you have a dog that enjoys hard treats and loves peanut butter, these are a great choice. However, if your dog has dental issues or prefers softer treats, consider a different option.

7.5 /10
β€” Good