Pupford Beef Collagen Stick, 10-oz bag, 10 count
In a Nutshell
- Some dogs love the taste and chewing duration.
- Quality control issues with color and texture.
- Safety concerns including vomiting and territorial behavior.
- Durability issues with shards causing potential obstruction.
Quick Verdict
Pupford Collagen Sticks have mixed reviews, with some dogs loving them and others experiencing issues like vomiting and territorial behavior. Quality control seems inconsistent, with changes in color and texture noted.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Dogs have experienced vomiting and territorial behavior after consuming the treats.
Prevention: Monitor the dog closely after giving the treat and avoid using if the dog has a sensitive stomach.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Taste (3)
Many dogs enjoy the taste of the treats.
-
Engaging Chew (1)
Long lasting chew keeps dogs busy for extended periods.
Cons
-
Quality Changes (1) critical
Recent batches of a very dark color significantly altering the taste and making dogs avoid the treats.
-
Health Issues (2) major
Several cases of dogs vomiting and showing aggressive behavior after consuming the treats.
-
Durability (2) high
The treats break apart into sharp shards, posing a choking hazard.
-
End (1) high
The product falls apart in shards and not a good fit for us.
Tip: Soak the sticks in water to soften.
-
Harmful (1) high
My pup loves this brand of treats but I will never buy this specific treat again, he became extremely territorial.
Quality Trend: Declining
Several reports of changes in color and consistency leading to dogs avoiding the treats.
Generally positive
More negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Dog owners looking for long-lasting chews — Many dogs enjoy the long chew time, which can keep them occupied.
- • Owners of dogs who love chewing treats — Dogs love the taste, and the texture can make it a favorite toy.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of dogs with sensitive stomachs — Several reviews report cases of vomiting and gastrointestinal discomfort.
- • Pet owners concerned about choking hazards — The durability issues can lead to sharp shards, posing a choking hazard.
Durability & Care
Factors: Hardness of the stick, Quality control of batches, Dogs chewing habits
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Are Pupford Collagen Sticks safe for all dogs?
Not all dogs tolerate these well. Some reports of vomiting and aggressive behavior suggest suitability issues for certain dogs, especially those with sensitive stomachs.
Are these treats durable for heavy chewers?
These sticks can break apart into sharp shards, making them potentially dangerous for heavy chewers.
Are these treats good for long-term use?
The reviews indicate concerns on durability and the treats may break apart and the risks of chocking and obstructing food or airways.
Highlighted Reviews
"My 18 month old Westie girl just LOVES her chewie. We have had good luck with her enjoying Pupford treats so I decided to try these. They are now a favorite. If I need her to behave while I am working from home and have to be on the phone I pull out one of these and she focuses on that for a long ti..."
"We've been getting the Pupford Collagen sticks for several months. Our one year old Boston Terrier has LOVED them and annihilated everyone we gave him in less than two days. They were the medium tan sticks. The last one we just bought are very dark brown and it dog won't do anything with it excep..."
Bottom Line
While some dogs enjoy these treats, the inconsistent quality and potential safety risks make it a product to approach with caution. Consider other brands or closely monitor your dog if you choose to try these.