Wagner's Peanut Pieces Wild Bird Food, 10-lb bag
In a Nutshell
- Economical and popular among wildlife
- Consistent quality issues reported
- Shipping damage and packaging concerns
- Some users appreciate the price and value
Quick Verdict
Wagner's Peanut Pieces offer reasonable value but inconsistency in quality is a major concern, with multiple complaints of rancid and moldy peanuts.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Sections of bulk food sealing containing eggs and insect larvae unmutated and encased.
Prevention: All foodstuffs are best kept in frost-free environments, freezers recommended.
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Economical (3)
Competitive price and good economy per pound.
-
Popular with Wildlife (2)
Attracts a variety of wildlife including birds, squirrels, and deer.
-
Good for Both Small and Large Animals (2)
Suitable for both small and large animals.
Cons
-
Quality Issues (4) major
Multiple reports of rancid and moldy peanuts.
-
Packaging and Shipping Damage (2) major
Packaging often arrives damaged leading to spillage.
-
Debris and Dirty Contaminants (1) major
Presence of rocks, dirt clumps, and other contaminants in the product.
Tip: Ensure to visually inspect the entire batch before feeding to wildlife.
-
Low Quality (3) medium
Reports of the product being raw and chewy, with black spots/black junk on it.
Tip: Filter through a sifter before serving to pets to eliminate debris
Quality Trend: Declining
Quality issues are mentioned more frequently in newer reviews, indicating a decline in product quality over time.
mixed
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Wildlife enthusiasts with diverse animal visitors — The peanuts are popular among a wide range of wildlife, making it a good option for those looking to attract different types of animals.
- • Pet owners on a budget — The product is considered economical, offering a good value for the price.
✗ Skip If
- • Consumers expecting consistent high-quality products — The product has numerous quality complaints, including rancid and moldy peanuts.
- • Pet owners concerned about food safety — Reports of rocks and dirt mixed with the peanuts, posing a health risk.
Durability & Care
Factors: Storage conditions, Insect Infestation, Exposure to moisture.
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Inspect peanuts for any signs of mold or rancidity before use.
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
What sizes are available?
Are these peanuts whole or in pieces?
These peanuts are in pieces, not whole.
What animals are these peanuts suitable for?
The peanuts are suitable for a variety of wildlife including birds, squirrels, and deer.
What is the storage time frame if used indoors?
Stored in compact sealed containers, the anticipated shelf-life product run length is anticipated to endure up to 12-18 months.
Highlighted Reviews
"Wagner's Peanut Pieces: This 10 pound bag of peanut pieces was the most economical per pound. Bear in mind, these are pieces, not whole peanuts - but the squirrels, deer, birds and the foxes seem to find them quite tasty. So they worked, and helped provide some protein and fat into the creatures' ..."
"I have been buying these peanut pieces for some time but I have now received rancid peanuts in two consecutive orders. Chewy has been great about refunding my money but it's not worth the trouble of ordering and receiving the bags of peanuts only to open them and find a smelly, moldy bag of peanuts ..."
Bottom Line
If you're looking for an affordable wild bird food, Wagner's Peanut Pieces might be worth a try, but be prepared for potential quality issues. Buyers should monitor for signs of spoilage and consider a refund if problems arise.