Dr. Elsey's cleanprotein Turkey Recipe Wet Cat Food
In a Nutshell
- Significant decline in customer satisfaction due to formula changes.
- Many cats refuse to eat the new recipe.
- Positive aspects include healthy ingredients and recyclable packaging.
- Pricing is considered fair, but value for money is low.
- Buyers should research specific flavors and formulas before purchasing.
Quick Verdict
The product has a significant number of negative reviews due to changes in the formula and texture, making it unappealing to many cats. However, some users appreciate the healthy ingredients and recyclable packaging.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
High phosphorus content in new formula
Prevention: Consult with your vet and the brand regarding dietary needs
Rancid food in cans
Prevention: Reviewers to ask manufacturers to handle this problem= issue
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Healthy Ingredients (2)
The food is made with quality ingredients that are beneficial for cat health.
-
Recycling Packaging (1)
The packaging is recyclable, promoting sustainability.
-
Soft Textures (1)
Cats can enjoy the texture.
Cons
-
Formula Changes (5) major
The recent changes in the formula have made the food unappealing to many cats.
Tip: Consult with your vet and the brand regarding dietary needs
-
Dry Texture (4) minor
The new texture is too dry for some cats, making it unpalatable.
Tip: Will switched to chunky recipe.
-
Batch Variations (1) major
There are reports of inconsistent quality between batches, with some cans being rancid or exploding.
Tip: Reviewers have asked to Dr. Elsey’s to handle this quality issue
-
Value (1) major
High phosphorus makes forbidding for animals.
Tip: Will switch to lower phosphorus food.
Quality Trend: Declining
Many users report that the new formula is less dense and has a different texture, making it unpalatable for their cats. There are also concerns the manufacturing machine divides unequally.
positive
negative
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cat owners looking for healthy, low-phosphorus food — The product is made with quality ingredients and is considered healthy for cats.
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of picky eaters or cats with specific dietary needs — The recent formula changes have made the food unpalatable for many cats, and the high phosphorus content may not be suitable for some.
- • Budget-conscious buyers — The product is considered fair in price, but the value for money is low due to the formula issues and the fact that many cats refuse to eat it.
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is Dr. Elsey's Turkey Recipe Wet Food suitable for pre-diabetic cats?
Most users report that the high phosphorus in this food isn't suitable for cats with pre-diabetic conditions. We need to avoid prone type dryers if detected.
Is the formula dire definitely changed?
Majority answer. Yes, product consistency has affected. Never purchased another one could’ve been better.
Highlighted Reviews
"Healthiest food for both of my girls, really like the Elsey's as a strong kibble diet substitute."
"It seems to me that they've also changed the 2.75 cans which had a consistent formulation until now. My cats are unable to eat the new recipe and it has a high phosphorus content, which is a problem for one of my cats with a health condition."
Bottom Line
If your cat is picky or has dietary restrictions, this might not be the best option. Look for reviews on the specific formula and flavor you are considering. Consider alternative brands if your cat is pre-diabetic and you are also looking for prebiotics or probiotics for cats.