Newman's Own Organics Grain-Free Beef & Liver Canned Cat Food
In a Nutshell
- Mixed reviews on taste and texture
- Some cats love it, others refuse
- Organic ingredients well-received
- May need to be mixed with other foods
- Potential for mixed preferences and texture issues
Quick Verdict
The Newman's Own Organics Grain-Free Beef & Liver Canned Cat Food receives mixed reviews. Some cats enjoy the taste, but many find the texture unappealing. The food is generally well-received for its organic ingredients, but it may need to be mixed with other foods to make it more palatable. Overall, it's a decent option but may not cater to all cat's tastes.
Quick Stats
Pet Compatibility
Critical Warnings
Texture may be unpalatable for some cats, causing them to refuse to eat.
Prevention: Consider mixing with other foods
Pros & Cons
Pros
-
Organic Ingredients (5)
High-quality, organic ingredients are well-received by reviewers.
-
Healthy (7)
Health and environmental concerns from Newman's Own quality and ingredients.
-
Velour Formula (3)
Some cats like it, as it could be a game-changer.
-
Good Value (1)
Some reviewers mention its affordable price point
Cons
-
Textural Issues (10) major
Comments on the texture being sticky and thick give rise to complaint
Tip: Mix with kibble works well.
-
Refusal to Eat (6) major
Many cats refused to enjoy anything to do with the beef flavor food amounting to frustration
-
Vomit Issue (2) critical
Fluids and vomiting problem caused by beef & liver cannons/individual cans are also reported
Who Is This For?
✓ Best For
- • Cat owners looking for organic, grain-free options — Affordable and well-reviewed organic ingredients
✗ Skip If
- • Owners of picky eaters or cats with texture sensitivities — Many cats refuse to eat due to thick, sticky texture
Durability & Care
Cleaning Methods
Care Tips from Users
- 💡 Mix with kibble for better acceptance
Floor Compatibility
Rating Distribution
Common Questions
Is this food suitable for cats with allergies?
Some reviewers mention it's good for allergic cats, but others' allergic cats refused it.
How can I make this food more appealing to my cat?
Mixing with dry food or other wet foods can help.
Does this food have a strong smell?
Some reviewers mentioned a bad smell, but it's not consistent.
Highlighted Reviews
"Limited ingredients just what I need for my allergic cat. She loves it!"
"All of my cats did not like this flavor. I saw it was a very sticky texture to it."
Bottom Line
Cats seem to appreciate whether Newman's Own Organics beef and liver flavor satisfies their tastes. While some cats enjoy it and appear to love the taste, the number of reviews indicating dislike for the texture, as well as cats experiencing vomiting with this particular flavor, makes it less than an ideal choice for many customers. If you are purchasing this cat food, consider mixing it with other foods to cater to your cat’s preferences and potentially avoid any health issues.